ChamberOne

Electronic evidence under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam

By the ChamberOne team 6 minute read

India's law of evidence changed on 1 July 2024, when the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) replaced the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. For electronic evidence, the provision that matters most is Section 63, which succeeds the old Section 65B. The core rule is the same: a certificate is required to admit a printout or copy of an electronic record without producing the original device. But the certificate changed materially. It must now follow a prescribed format set out in a Schedule to the Act, it must be signed by both the person in charge of the device and an independent expert, and the format requires a hash value of the record. This article explains the statutory framework as it stands today, sets it against the old Section 65B, and identifies the practical points litigators need to understand.

Key points

  • Section 63 of the BSA replaced Section 65B from 1 July 2024, keeping the certificate requirement but adding a prescribed two-part Schedule format, an expert co-signature, and a mandatory hash value.
  • The certificate is still a condition precedent for secondary electronic evidence; oral evidence cannot replace it, and the principles in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar (2020) remain the leading authority under the new Act.
  • Section 63 expressly covers communication devices and semiconductor memory, and treats a chain of interconnected systems as a single device, which matters for cloud, mobile and enterprise data.
  • Problems with certificates almost always originate at collection: a record that was not hashed at acquisition cannot satisfy Part A or Part B of the Schedule, and a screenshot may not preserve the metadata a court will expect.
  • For matters that straddle the 1 July 2024 commencement date, the transitional position depends on the savings provisions and judicial directions in the specific proceedings, and should be verified.

The old framework: Section 65B and its troubled history

Section 65B was inserted into the Indian Evidence Act by the Information Technology Act, 2000. It provided that any information contained in an electronic record printed on paper, or stored or copied in optical or magnetic media produced by a computer, was deemed to be a document and admissible as evidence of the original, provided certain conditions were met. Those conditions required the device to have been in regular use, information to have been regularly fed in during the ordinary course of activities, the device to have been working properly, and the output to reproduce what was fed in.

Section 65B(4) added a certificate requirement. Someone with official responsibility for the management and operation of the relevant device had to sign a certificate identifying the record, describing how it was produced, and addressing the statutory conditions. No form was prescribed; the content was set out in the section itself.

For nearly two decades, courts disagreed on whether the certificate was truly mandatory. The Supreme Court eventually settled the question in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal (2020) 7 SCC 1, where a three-judge bench reaffirmed that the certificate is a mandatory condition precedent for secondary electronic evidence, that oral evidence cannot substitute for it, and that a party unable to obtain the certificate from someone controlling the device may apply to the court to direct that person to produce it.

How the BSA restructures electronic evidence

The BSA came into force on 1 July 2024, replacing the Indian Evidence Act in its entirety. Electronic evidence is now governed principally by Sections 57, 61, 62 and 63, together with the definitions in Section 2.

Section 2(1)(d) defines document to expressly include electronic and digital records, with illustrations covering emails, server logs, files on computers, laptops and smartphones, messages, websites and location data. Section 61 provides that nothing in the Act shall be used to deny admissibility of an electronic or digital record on the ground that it is electronic, and that such records have the same legal effect, validity and enforceability as other documents.

Section 62 provides that the contents of electronic records may be proved in accordance with Section 63. Section 57 sets out what counts as primary evidence and includes explanations relevant to electronic records: where a record is stored in multiple files simultaneously, each file is primary evidence; and where a video recording is simultaneously stored and transmitted, each stored recording is primary evidence.

Section 65B, Evidence Act 1872
  • No prescribed certificate format; contents set out in the section
  • Signed by the responsible person for the device only
  • No requirement for a hash value
  • No explicit mention of communication devices or semiconductor memory
  • Certificate mandatory for secondary evidence (settled in 2020)
Section 63, BSA 2023 (from 1 July 2024)
  • Certificate must follow the Schedule: Part A and Part B
  • Signed by the person in charge AND an independent expert
  • Hash value of the record required, with algorithm stated
  • Expressly covers communication devices and semiconductor memory
  • Certificate remains mandatory for secondary electronic evidence
Section 65B (old) versus Section 63 BSA (current)

Section 63: the conditions for admissibility

Section 63(1) defines computer output broadly to include information printed on paper or stored, recorded or copied in optical, magnetic or semiconductor media produced by a computer or communication device. The express mention of communication devices and semiconductor memory is a meaningful expansion from the old Section 65B, and brings mobile phones, flash drives and solid-state storage clearly within the provision.

Section 63(2) sets out four conditions the certificate must address: the device was regularly used to create, store or process information for the relevant activities during the material period; information of the kind contained in the record was regularly fed in during the ordinary course of those activities; the device was operating properly, or any malfunction did not affect the accuracy of the record; and the output reproduces or is derived from information fed in during the ordinary course.

Section 63(3) addresses the common situation where data passes through several systems, such as a cloud service or messaging platform. It deems a combination of devices, computer systems, networks, computer resources and intermediaries used over the relevant period to be a single device. A party relying on records stored in cloud infrastructure therefore does not need to certify each server in the chain independently.

The Schedule: what the certificate must contain

The most significant practical change in the BSA is the prescribed certificate format. The Schedule to the Act, referenced by Section 63(4)(c), sets out a two-part form. Under the old Section 65B, the law described what the certificate had to say but prescribed no standard form; courts received certificates in varying formats and disputes arose over their sufficiency.

Part A is completed by the party producing the record. It requires identification of the source device by type (computer or storage media, DVR, mobile, flash drive, CD or DVD, server, cloud, or other), together with the make, model, colour, serial number, and IMEI, MAC address or cloud ID as applicable. The deponent must confirm the device was under lawful control, was regularly used for the activities in question, and was working properly. Critically, the form requires the hash value of the record, specifying the algorithm used, and a hash report must be enclosed.

Part B is completed by the expert. It follows the same structure as Part A, requiring the expert to confirm the source and device particulars and to state the hash value and algorithm independently. The expert signs with their name and designation.

A hash value is a fixed-length digital fingerprint of a file. If a single bit of the record changes after the hash is computed, the hash changes. Recording the hash in the certificate means the method of collection is visible on the face of the document and any subsequent alteration can be detected. This is a genuine improvement in evidentiary integrity over the old Section 65B, which had no equivalent requirement.

Leading judgments and their continuing relevance

Because Section 63 tracks Section 65B with additions rather than replacing it with an entirely different structure, the leading judgments under Section 65B continue to guide courts applying Section 63.

Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal (2020) 7 SCC 1 remains the most important authority. It confirmed the certificate is a mandatory condition precedent for secondary electronic evidence; oral evidence cannot substitute for it; and a party that cannot obtain the certificate may apply to the court to direct the person in control of the device to produce it. The court also indicated that the certificate may in appropriate cases be produced at a later stage, subject to the court's discretion.

Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer (2014) 10 SCC 473 established that the certificate is mandatory for secondary evidence but not where the original device is produced in court as primary evidence. That carve-out is preserved under Section 63 and reflected in Section 57's expanded definition of primary evidence.

Sonu v. State of Haryana (2017) 8 SCC 570 established that an objection about a missing or defective certificate must generally be raised when the electronic record is marked as an exhibit. Raising it for the first time on appeal is ordinarily too late, as it concerns the mode of proof rather than the relevance or weight of the evidence.

Where certificates commonly go wrong

Problems with Section 63 certificates typically originate at the point of collection, well before anyone drafts the form. If the record was not hashed at acquisition, there is no reference hash to record in the certificate and no reliable way to show the record has not changed since.

Screenshots of chat messages or web pages are a frequent source of difficulty. A screenshot shows the content visible on screen at a moment in time but loses metadata and provenance information that would be preserved by a forensic export. The certificate can describe a screenshot, but opposing counsel will probe whether it accurately represents the full underlying record.

Device particulars in the certificate must match the acquisition records precisely. Serial numbers, IMEI numbers and account identifiers that differ between the certificate and the collection records give the opposing party a basis to object. The expert required for Part B must be someone who can genuinely speak to the acquisition method and the integrity of the record, not simply a convenient signatory.

Do
  • Hash the record at acquisition and record the algorithm and value immediately
  • Use a forensic export or imaging method rather than a screenshot where possible
  • Ensure device make, model, serial number and identifiers match across all documents
  • Have the expert sign Part B on the basis of their actual knowledge of the acquisition
Don't
  • Rely on a certificate prepared for earlier proceedings without checking it matches the current record
  • Assume oral evidence can cure a missing or defective certificate
  • Leave the expert signature to a manager who did not handle the data
  • Raise a certificate objection for the first time on appeal after failing to object at exhibit stage
Section 63 certificate: common errors and how to avoid them

Transitional matters and practical steps

The BSA came into force on 1 July 2024. Its application to proceedings already under way on that date depends on the transitional and savings provisions and on how courts apply the general principle that procedural law changes apply to pending proceedings unless they affect vested rights. Practitioners handling matters that straddle the commencement date should verify the current position by reference to any applicable savings clause and any judicial direction given in the specific proceedings.

For fresh proceedings commenced on or after 1 July 2024, Section 63 applies, the old Section 65B is no longer in force, and the prescribed Schedule format is what courts will require.

The certificate cannot be assembled at the last moment. The information it requires, particularly the hash value and the expert's verification of the acquisition method, comes from decisions made when the evidence is first collected.

  1. 1

    Identify all relevant devices, accounts and systems at the outset of the matter

  2. 2

    Preserve by imaging or authenticated export before routine deletion or reuse can occur

  3. 3

    Compute and record the hash value of each acquired file, noting algorithm, date, time and place

  4. 4

    Document every transfer of the material to maintain an unbroken chain of custody

  5. 5

    Instruct an expert who can sign Part B on the basis of their own knowledge of the acquisition

  6. 6

    Use the prescribed Schedule format without adaptation or abbreviation

  7. 7

    File the certificate together with the hash report each time the record is submitted

Sources

  1. Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 — Act 47 of 2023 (Indian Kanoon)
  2. Schedule to the BSA 2023, Certificate under Section 63(4)(c) — AdvocateKhoj bare act
  3. Section 63 BSA 2023: Admissibility of Electronic Evidence — King Stubb and Kasiva
  4. Electronic Evidence under the BSA 2023: Section 63 Certificates Explained — Spectra Forensics
  5. Electronic Evidence under the BSA 2023: Has Section 63 Really Made Proof Easier? — Lawful Legal
  6. Section 65B Evidence Act / Section 63 BSA — Juristco

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Electronic Evidence under the BSA 2023 | ChamberOne