Ethics opinions on AI: the common themes
By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read
Professional bodies around the world have started to publish views on lawyers using AI. They differ in form, in force and in detail. A compliance partner trying to read them all will drown. Yet when you read several side by side, the same handful of themes appears again and again: competence, confidentiality, supervision, candour to the court and fair fees. This article does not summarise any particular opinion, since you should read the current text from your own regulator or bar. It describes the themes, explains what each tends to mean in daily work, and turns them into a checklist you can adapt.
Key points
- Competence, confidentiality, supervision, candour and fees recur across professional guidance on AI.
- Read your own regulator's or bar's current text rather than relying on summaries.
- Turn each theme into a few yes or no questions that practice heads complete once a year.
- Record the source of each point from the text that binds your firm.
- Treat themes as a map and take advice where your position is uncertain.
Why read for themes
Individual opinions date quickly, and a summary written today may be wrong after the next publication. Themes are steadier. They reflect duties that already existed, applied to a new tool.
Reading for themes also helps firms working across several markets. Your lawyers may be bound by different bodies, and a policy built on common principles is easier to maintain than one patched together from each text. You will still need to check each regulator's own wording for anything that binds you.
Competence
The first theme is that a lawyer should understand the tools they use well enough to judge the benefits and risks. In practice that means knowing that models can produce confident errors, understanding what happens to data, and being able to check the output. It does not mean everyone must become a technician.
- Do the people using the tool know its limits?
- Has the firm tried it on non-client examples first?
- Is there training, and is it recorded?
Confidentiality
The second theme concerns client information. Putting it into a tool may disclose it to a third party. Guidance generally points toward understanding how the provider stores and uses the data, choosing tools with suitable terms, and being cautious with consumer products.
- Do we know whether inputs are stored, used for training or processed abroad?
- Are staff barred from using personal accounts for client work?
- Do clients' own instructions or panel terms restrict tool use?
Supervision
The third theme is that lawyers and firms stay responsible for the work of those they supervise, and that includes work done with the help of tools. Partners are expected to set sensible rules and to make sure people follow them. Delegating to a tool does not lower the standard of review.
- Is there a written policy that staff have read?
- Does a lawyer review AI-assisted output before it reaches a client or court?
- Is there a way to check that the rules are followed?
Candour to the court and others
The fourth theme is honesty with tribunals and others who rely on what lawyers say. The recurring concern is invented or misquoted authorities appearing in submissions. Guidance generally expects a lawyer to verify what they put before a court, and some courts may give directions about disclosing AI use in filings. Check the rules of the forum where you appear.
- Is every authority opened and read by a person before it is cited?
- Do we know whether the court expects disclosure of AI use?
- Are quotations checked word by word?
Fees and billing
The fifth theme is fairness in what clients pay. If a tool saves time, a client who is billed by the hour may expect that saving to show in the bill. Billing for time not actually spent, or charging a client for the firm's learning, draws criticism in much of the guidance. Firms using fixed fees face the opposite question: whether the fee still reflects the work.
The tool itself may be a cost the firm absorbs or passes on. If you intend to charge for it, say so in advance and check what your regulator allows.
- Do bills reflect time genuinely spent?
- Is any charge for tools agreed with the client in advance?
- Bill time genuinely spent
- Agree any charge for tools with the client in advance
- Bill for time not actually spent
- Charge a client for the firm's learning
Communication with clients
A sixth theme is keeping clients informed. Opinions differ on when disclosure of AI use is needed and when it is merely good practice. Where use is substantial, affects cost or involves unusual data handling, telling the client is the safer course. Check what applies to you, and record what the client was told.
Turning themes into a one-page checklist
Suppose a compliance partner in a mid-sized firm collects the questions above into a single page, with a yes or no box next to each. Each practice group head completes it once a year for the tools their team uses, and the compliance partner reviews the answers and follows up on any 'no'. The page is short enough to be completed honestly.
Link the checklist to the specific guidance that binds your firm. A column headed 'source' with the regulator's name and a reference to the relevant paragraph, filled in by you after reading the current text, turns a generic checklist into a firm-specific one. Do not copy a paragraph reference from a secondary summary.
- 1Each practice head completes the page for their tools
- 2The compliance partner reviews the answers
- 3Follow up on any 'no' with who will fix it and by when
- 4Keep the answers from year to year
- 5Repeat next year
- Then back to step 1.
Using the checklist in a real review
A checklist only works if someone acts on a 'no'. When a practice head answers no to a question, the compliance partner should ask what would turn it into a yes, who will do it and by when. Often the fix is small: a short note to staff, a change of tool setting, a five-minute briefing at a team meeting.
Keep the answers from year to year. A pattern of repeated 'no' answers in one team usually points to a missing owner or missing time, not to carelessness.
Where the themes stop
Themes are a map, not a rule book. They cannot tell you whether a particular use is permitted in your jurisdiction, and they gloss over real differences between bodies. Use them to organise your thinking, then read the text that binds you and take advice where the position is uncertain. Review the checklist whenever new guidance appears.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Client confidentiality and AI tools: a checklist before you paste anything in
The questions to answer about retention, training use, access, hosting and sub-processors before client information goes into any AI tool.
5 minute readShadow AI in law firms: staff are already using it, so what next?
Why bans fail, how to find out what is being used, and how to offer an approved alternative with clear rules.
5 minute readWriting a law firm AI policy: an outline you can adapt
Six sections that a short, usable AI policy needs, with the questions each one should answer.
4 minute read