ChamberOne

Singapore: PDPA obligations when using AI in a law firm

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

A Singapore law firm that uses an AI tool on client material is handling personal data, and often sending it to a vendor that may sit in another country. The Personal Data Protection Act sets data protection obligations for organisations. The Personal Data Protection Commission publishes guidance on them. This article is general information, not advice. It shows how the main obligations map onto the questions a firm should ask before using AI.

Key points

  • Map consent, notification, protection and transfer limitation onto each AI tool you consider.
  • Legal files contain data about people other than the client, so think about them too.
  • Get written vendor answers on locations, training use, retention and security.
  • Keep a register and an incident plan, and take advice for sensitive or novel arrangements.

The obligations that matter most for AI

The PDPC describes a set of data protection obligations for organisations in Singapore. Four of them are especially relevant when a firm adopts an AI tool: consent, notification, protection and transfer limitation. Accountability, which concerns having policies and practices and being able to show them, ties the others together.

The exact wording, exceptions and recent changes should be taken from the PDPA and the PDPC's own pages, not from a summary like this one. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar as well.

Consent and notification

In outline, organisations are expected to tell individuals why they collect, use or disclose personal data, and to obtain consent unless an exception applies. Think about how this works in a law firm. A client gives you data to receive legal advice. Would they expect it to be processed by an AI service run by a third party? If your engagement terms and privacy notice do not mention it, consider whether they should.

The information in a legal file is not only about the client. It names opponents, witnesses, employees and family members, who have not dealt with the firm directly. Think about how your obligations apply to them, and take advice on the exceptions that may be relevant to legal work.

Decide when to tell clients specifically. For sensitive matters, or where a client asks, record whether AI will be used, and respect a decision not to.

The client
  • Gives data to receive legal advice
  • May not expect an AI service run by a third party to process it
  • Engagement terms and privacy notice may need to mention it
Others named in the file
  • Opponents, witnesses, employees and family members
  • They have not dealt with the firm directly
  • Take advice on the exceptions that may apply to legal work
Whose personal data is in a legal file

Protection

Organisations are expected to make reasonable security arrangements to protect personal data in their possession or control. For AI, that includes the vendor. Ask what security measures the vendor has, who can access your content, how it is stored, how long it is kept and how incidents are handled.

Reasonable depends on the sensitivity of the data and the risk. Client files from a family or criminal matter justify more than an internal staff newsletter. Match the tool to the data. Put in place access controls on your own side, such as two-step sign-in and limits on who may upload to the tool.

Transfer limitation

The PDPA restricts transferring personal data outside Singapore unless certain conditions are met, including that the recipient provides a standard of protection comparable to that under the Act. Many AI services process data in other countries. Find out where your vendor processes and stores data, including through sub-processors.

Contractual terms are a common way to address this, but the right approach depends on the facts. Ask for written answers about locations and the protections that apply to the data, and take advice on whether your arrangements meet the transfer requirements.

A due diligence checklist for AI vendors

  1. 1

    Where is our data processed and stored, and by whom?

  2. 2

    Is our data used to train or improve models, and can this be turned off?

  3. 3

    How long is data kept, and how can it be deleted?

  4. 4

    What security measures protect our content, and who can access it?

  5. 5

    How will we be told about an incident, and how quickly?

  6. 6

    What contractual terms deal with transfers outside Singapore?

  7. 7

    Can AI features be restricted to certain matters or switched off?

Accountability and records

Firms are expected to have policies and practices that meet their obligations and to be able to show them. Appoint a person responsible for data protection. Keep a register of AI tools, with the purpose, the vendor's answers and your decision. Include AI in your incident and breach response plan, and log what is sent to which tool, so that you can find out which clients are affected if something goes wrong.

Train staff. Make clear which tools are approved, what may and may not be put into them and how to report a problem.

Where this article stops

This article does not cover every obligation under the PDPA, such as retention, access and correction, or breach notification, and it does not address your professional duties of confidentiality and privilege. It does not say whether a given AI arrangement complies. Those depend on your facts.

For authority, go to the PDPC's guidance and to your professional body. Where the data is sensitive or the arrangement is novel, take advice before you start.

A hypothetical example

Suppose a Singapore firm wants to use an AI tool to prepare chronologies from client emails in a commercial dispute. The data protection officer asks the vendor three questions in writing: where is content processed, is it used for training and how long is it retained. The answers show overseas processing and optional training use.

The firm turns training use off, records the vendor's answers, takes advice on the transfer position and adds a line about AI-assisted processing to its engagement terms. It also decides that the tool will not be used on matters where the client has asked for no third-party processing. None of that is dramatic. It is the habit of asking before adopting, and writing down what was said.

Communicating with clients

Plain information helps clients. A short paragraph in the engagement letter can say that the firm may use AI tools to assist with some tasks, that a lawyer reviews all output, that data may be processed outside Singapore by the tool's provider and that the client can ask the firm not to use such tools on their matter. Take advice on the wording, then offer a simple way for clients to ask questions or opt out where you can honour it.

Sources

  1. PDPC Singapore: Data Protection Obligations

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Singapore: PDPA obligations when using AI in a law firm