ChamberOne

Court rules on generative AI disclosure: how to stay compliant

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

A litigator who appears in three courts may face three different positions on generative AI. One expects nothing. One expects a declaration. One restricts use for certain documents. A directions order in the middle of a case may add a fourth. No firm can keep this in its head, and the cost of getting it wrong falls on the lawyer who signed the filing. This article is for litigators and the clerks who prepare their filings. It describes a routine, so that compliance does not depend on who happens to remember.

Key points

  • Rules differ by court and change, so build a routine and not a memory.
  • Check every applicable instrument at the start and before major filings, and record what you found.
  • Ask preparers exactly how they used tools before anyone signs a declaration.
  • Keep a verification table for authorities, and brief clerks, counsel and experts.

Why a routine beats memory

Court rules on AI are new and many are still being revised. A practice note issued this year may be amended next term. Judges may also issue directions in a single case. If your compliance relies on a partner remembering what a court said six months ago, it will fail on the day it matters.

A routine puts the checking in the process. It does not need clever people. It needs a checklist and a place to record the answer.

Step one: find every applicable instrument

At the start of a matter, and again before each major filing, list the courts and tribunals involved. For each, look for practice directions, practice notes, rules of court, judges' standing orders and any directions made in your case. Use the court's own website or registry, not secondary commentary.

Record where you looked, the date, and what you found, including 'nothing found'. A note saying 'checked the court's website on this date, no AI direction' is evidence that you took care.

Step two: sort the requirements

Instruments tend to fall into a few kinds. Read each one for which applies and take advice where unsure.

  • Restrictions on using AI to produce particular kinds of document, often evidence.
  • A requirement to declare or certify that AI was or was not used.
  • A requirement that all citations and quotations be verified, sometimes with a statement to that effect.
  • Orders about records you must keep and produce on request.
  • Warnings about consequences, such as costs orders or referral to a regulator.

Step three: apply it to each filing

Add a line to your filing checklist: 'AI rules checked for this court, date, by whom'. If a declaration is needed, the lawyer who signs it must know whether it is true. That means asking the people who prepared the document how they used tools, including research assistants, translation tools and the AI features inside your word processor.

Be exact. If a rule asks whether AI was used 'in preparing' a document, decide in advance how your firm reads that for spell checkers, transcription and search. If you are unsure, ask the court or take advice.

Step four: keep evidence of verification

Whatever the rule says, courts expect lawyers to check what they file. Make that visible. For each authority cited, note who found the source, what it was checked against and when. A simple table on the file is enough: citation, source opened, person, date.

Keep the prompts and outputs for any significant AI-assisted work for as long as the file is held, subject to your confidentiality rules. If a question arises later, you will be able to show what was done.

  1. 1Find every applicable instrument
  2. 2Sort the requirements
  3. 3Apply them to each filing
  4. 4Keep evidence of verification
  5. 5Check again before the next major filing
  6. Then back to step 1.
The court-rules routine

Brief the whole team

Filing errors often arise at the edges: a trainee drafting a skeleton, a paralegal preparing a bundle index, a barrister's clerk, an expert. Tell everyone who touches a filing what the court expects. Include external counsel and experts in your instructions.

For clerks, make the AI check a fixed step, as routine as checking the page limit or the font size. A short checklist taped to the filing guide will do.

Handling the case where you did not draft it

Sometimes a filing is prepared by someone outside your firm: counsel instructed by you, an overseas agent, a litigant's earlier solicitors. You may not know what tools they used. If the rules ask for a declaration, you must be able to say something truthful. Ask the person who prepared it, in writing, and keep the answer.

If they cannot or will not say, do not guess. Tell the court that you do not know, or decline to give a declaration you cannot support, and take advice on how to proceed. A careful, honest answer is better than a confident one that turns out to be wrong.

Make this part of your instructions to external counsel from the start. A line in the instruction letter asking them to tell you how AI is used on the work, and to follow the court's rules, costs nothing and prevents most of these problems.

When the rules are unclear

If the rule is ambiguous or silent, act on the cautious reading. Verify citations fully. Avoid AI for evidence. Consider telling the court or the other side if you used AI in a significant way and an informal note would be helpful. Ask the registry how it expects the rule to apply. Keep a record of what you asked and what you were told.

Be wary of assuming that silence means permission. Courts may react to a problem with new directions, and a firm that has been careful will be better placed.

Do
  • Act on the cautious reading
  • Verify citations fully
  • Avoid AI for evidence
  • Ask the registry
Don't
  • Assume silence means permission
  • Guess how external counsel used AI
When a court's AI rule is unclear

A short scenario

Suppose a litigation team files in two courts in the same week. The clerk's checklist shows that one court has an AI declaration requirement and the other does not. The associate who drafted the submissions confirms that she used a tool for a first outline and that every citation was checked. The partner signs the declaration, knowing it is accurate, and the verification table is on the file. Nothing dramatic happened, which is the point of a routine.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next