Data residency and law firm AI: what to ask your vendor
By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read
A vendor says, 'Your data is stored in your country.' It sounds like the end of the matter. It is not. Storing data and processing it are different things, and a feature that sends text to an AI provider may carry that text abroad for a few seconds or keep it for longer. For managing partners and IT leads, the useful skill is knowing which questions to ask and which answers to treat as firm. This article lists them. It does not say what any law requires. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar, and any duties you owe clients.
Key points
- Ask separately where data is stored and where it is processed, since AI features can move text elsewhere.
- Ask which third parties receive text, in which country, and whether they store it or train on it.
- Ask whether the features can be switched off and whether you can see a record of what was sent.
- Get answers in writing, keep a register of tools and review it regularly.
Storage is not processing
Data at rest is the files and records held on the vendor's servers. Data in use is what is read and handled when a feature runs. A vendor can hold your documents in one country and send parts of them elsewhere when you press a button.
AI features are the common case. To produce a summary, the text may be sent to a model provider that runs in another country. A statement about where data is stored says nothing about that. Ask about both.
- Files and records held on the vendor's servers
- Ask which country, where backups sit and who operates them
- Ask what happens when the contract ends
- What is read and handled when a feature runs
- Text may go to a model provider in another country
- Ask which features send text to a third party
- Ask whether you can switch them off
Questions about storage
- In which country or countries are our documents and database stored?
- Where are backups held, and in which country?
- Who operates the infrastructure: the vendor itself or a hosting company, and where is it based?
- Can we choose the location, and what happens if we want it changed?
- What happens to our data if we end the contract, and how long until it is deleted?
Questions about processing and AI
- Which features send our text to a third party, and which party is it?
- In which country is that text processed?
- Is the text stored by the third party, for how long, and is it used for training?
- Can we switch those features off for the firm? What exactly stops when we do?
- Is there a record we can see of what was sent, when and by whom?
- Will you tell us in advance if the third party or its location changes?
Cross-border transfers
Moving personal data across a border may be regulated in your country, and the rules differ widely. Some systems restrict transfers unless conditions are met. Others allow them with notice or contractual terms. Client confidentiality rules and client contracts may add restrictions of their own, and in-house clients sometimes require that their data stay in a specific place.
Do not rely on a vendor's assurance that it is 'compliant'. Ask what it has done and how, read the contract terms, and take advice where the matter is sensitive.
Which questions have clear answers
Good vendors can answer most of the above in a sentence or two. Where is it stored, who processes it, what is kept, and whether it can be switched off are factual questions with factual answers. If a vendor cannot say where data goes, that is itself an answer.
Treat vague phrases with care: 'enterprise-grade', 'bank-level security' and 'fully compliant' tell you nothing. Ask for the name of the sub-processor, the country and the contract term. Be equally careful with answers that change between sales calls and the written terms. The contract governs.
Getting it in writing
Ask for the answers in a document you can keep: a data processing agreement, a security page, or a written reply from the vendor. Record the date. Ask for a list of sub-processors and for notice of changes. Check that the contract says what happens on termination.
Keep a short register of each tool the firm uses, with the answers to these questions and the date of the last review. When a client asks where their data goes, the register gives you a quick and accurate answer.
Checking the answers you receive
A vendor's answers are only as good as your follow-up. If the reply is 'we use leading providers', ask for the names. If it is 'data stays in the region', ask whether that covers text sent for AI features. If it is 'we are certified', ask for the certificate, the scope and the date. A vendor with good answers will be glad to give them, and one without will start to hedge.
Compare the sales answers with the written terms and the security documents. If they disagree, ask which governs and get that in writing. Disagreements between the two are common and usually favour the vendor.
Involve whoever handles your professional indemnity insurance and your data protection obligations. They may have questions of their own and may know of requirements you have not considered.
- Ask for the names behind 'leading providers'
- Ask for the certificate, scope and date
- Compare sales answers with the written terms
- Rely on 'enterprise-grade' or 'fully compliant'
- Accept a sales answer that disagrees with the contract
A short scenario
Suppose a four-lawyer firm wants to try an AI summarising feature. The IT lead sends the vendor five questions: where is text processed, who receives it, is it stored, can we turn it off and can we see what was sent? The vendor answers four in writing within a day and says it will come back on the fifth. The IT lead records the four answers, notes the gap, and asks again. The firm starts with the feature off until the last answer arrives. No time was wasted, and nobody in the firm had to guess.
Telling clients
Some clients will ask directly. Prepare a short, accurate statement: where files are stored, which features send text elsewhere, where that text goes, and what you can switch off. If a client has restrictions, check the register and tell them honestly what you can and cannot do.
If you cannot meet a client's requirement with a particular tool, say so, and agree another way, such as not using AI features on that matter.
What ChamberOne says about AI and data
- With AI features off, nothing is sent to an AI provider.
- With AI features on, the text needed for a request is sent to the AI provider for that feature, OpenAI or Anthropic.
- The Security and AI page says what is sent and on what terms.
What it does not do
- With AI features on, text goes to the AI provider outside the country where ChamberOne is hosted.
- ChamberOne does not say whether this meets any particular country's rules on transfers. Check with your regulator or bar.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Corporate Transparency Act: who must still file beneficial ownership reports
FinCEN's August 2026 final rule made permanent the end of BOI reporting for US-formed companies; only certain foreign entities still file.
5 minute readClient confidentiality and AI tools: a checklist before you paste anything in
The questions to answer about retention, training use, access, hosting and sub-processors before client information goes into any AI tool.
5 minute readShadow AI in law firms: staff are already using it, so what next?
Why bans fail, how to find out what is being used, and how to offer an approved alternative with clear rules.
5 minute read