ChamberOne

US: ABA Formal Opinion 512 on generative AI, in plain language

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

In 2024 the American Bar Association's ethics committee issued Formal Opinion 512, its first formal guidance on lawyers using generative AI tools. It is guidance, not law, and state bars set the rules that bind a lawyer in practice. Even so, it is the document most US firms point to when they write an AI policy. This article walks through the themes the opinion addresses, in plain language. It is a summary for orientation, so read the opinion itself and your own state bar's guidance before you rely on any of it.

Key points

  • Opinion 512 applies existing conduct duties to generative AI and is guidance, not law.
  • Understand the tool, know what happens to client information, and decide when client consent is needed.
  • The lawyer who files a document is responsible for it, so check every authority.
  • Managers should have a policy and training, and fees should reflect work actually done.

What the opinion is, and what it is not

The opinion applies existing professional conduct principles to a new kind of tool. It does not create a new set of AI rules. Its starting point is that a lawyer's existing duties stay the same, whatever technology the lawyer uses.

It is issued by a committee of the national bar association. State bars and courts may take a different view, and several have published their own guidance. If you practise in one state, the question to ask is what your state's rules and bar say, with Opinion 512 as a useful map of the issues.

Competence

The opinion treats competence as including a reasonable understanding of the tool. That does not mean becoming an engineer. It means knowing, in a practical sense, what the tool can and cannot do, that it can produce plausible but wrong output, and that the lawyer must judge whether to use it on a given task.

In practice, that points to learning before use and to continued learning, since tools change. A lawyer who has never tested a tool on a task they know well is poorly placed to judge its output on a task they do not.

Confidentiality

This is the topic most firms worry about. The opinion treats entering client information into a tool as raising confidentiality questions, because the information may be stored, used or seen by others. The lawyer has to understand how the tool handles what is entered.

The opinion discusses the difference between tools that use inputs to train models that others use and tools that do not, and the role of client consent. Read that part closely. Check what your state bar says about the form of consent and what counts as informed, because a general line in an engagement letter may not be enough.

Communication

Clients are entitled to be kept reasonably informed. The opinion considers when that means telling a client about AI use. Circumstances matter: whether the client asked, whether the tool involves client information, and whether its use is significant to the work or its cost.

A practical approach is to put a short, honest explanation in the engagement letter and to be ready to answer questions in conversation. Where a client has said not to use AI, honour that.

Candor to the tribunal and meritorious claims

The opinion addresses the now familiar problem of fabricated citations. A lawyer who files a document is responsible for it, whoever or whatever drafted it. Checking authorities in a reliable source before filing is the lawyer's job.

Courts and judges may also have their own orders on AI. The opinion's general point sits alongside those orders. Check the local rules and any standing orders for the court you are in.

Supervision

Partners and managers are expected to have reasonable measures in place so that lawyers and staff under them use AI consistently with the lawyer's duties. That points to a written policy, training, and a way of finding out what tools people use.

It also covers outside providers, including the vendors of AI tools. The opinion treats them as relevant to supervision, so due diligence on the tool's terms and security belongs in your process.

Fees

The opinion considers how lawyers may charge for AI-assisted work. The theme is that fees must be reasonable and that time billed should reflect the work actually done. Billing a client for hours that AI saved raises obvious problems, and so does passing on general overhead as a separate cost without agreement.

The sensible course is to agree the basis of charging in the engagement letter and to review your billing practice against your state's guidance. Keep time entries specific enough that a client can see what was done, and record in the file how AI was used on larger tasks.

Where states and courts may differ

Because the opinion is national guidance, the details of the duties are set locally. A state may use different wording in its conduct rules, may have issued its own AI guidance, and may have a view on consent that is stricter or looser than the national committee's. Individual courts and judges may require disclosure or certification for filings that involved AI, and those requirements vary between courts and can change.

A firm with offices in more than one state should map the differences once, in writing, and keep the map updated. The point of doing that is not to find the weakest standard. It is to have one routine that satisfies the strictest place you work in, so that nobody has to remember which rules apply where.

Opinion 512
  • Applies existing conduct duties to a new kind of tool
  • Issued by a committee of the national bar association
  • Guidance, not law
States and courts
  • May use different wording in their conduct rules
  • May have published their own AI guidance
  • May take a stricter or looser view on consent
  • Individual courts may have their own orders
National guidance and local rules

A short checklist to take away

  1. 1

    Read the opinion itself and your state bar's AI guidance, and note any differences.

  2. 2

    Test each tool on a task you know well before relying on it for one you do not.

  3. 3

    Find out what each vendor does with inputs, and decide what client information may be entered.

  4. 4

    Write an engagement letter paragraph on AI use and agree how it will be charged.

  5. 5

    Verify every authority before filing, and check each court's own rules.

  6. 6

    Adopt a firm policy and train everyone who works under you.

Sources

  1. American Bar Association, Formal Opinion 512: Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next