Arbitration and AI: published guidance for tribunals and counsel
By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read
Arbitration depends on confidentiality, party autonomy and trust in the tribunal. AI tools touch all three. Counsel may use them to review documents or draft submissions. Tribunals may be tempted to use them to organise a record or draft procedural orders. Several institutions and professional bodies have published guidelines on the subject, and more are likely to follow. This article does not summarise any one of them, since the texts change and you should read the current versions yourself. It describes the themes that recur, and how a practitioner can prepare before the first procedural order raises the question.
Key points
- Read the current guidance from the institution and the rules your parties chose; summaries go out of date.
- Recurring themes are disclosure, confidentiality, responsibility, non-delegation of decisions and accuracy.
- Prepare a short internal note on permitted tools, data handling, checking and disclosure before the first procedural meeting.
- Consider proposing a simple protocol on AI use early in the case.
- Verify every authority and quotation, especially foreign law, however a draft was produced.
Why arbitration raises its own questions
Court proceedings are mostly public and governed by procedural rules that apply to everyone. Arbitration rests on an agreement, often with confidential documents, and a tribunal chosen for its judgement. That shapes the issues.
A tribunal's decision-making is personal. Parties appointed these individuals for their expertise, and they expect these individuals to decide. The confidentiality of hearings and documents is a core attraction of the process. And the parties often come from several legal systems with different expectations about technology.
Themes in published guidance
Guidelines issued by institutions and professional bodies differ in detail, but the same themes keep appearing. Read the current text from the institution that administers your case, and the rules chosen by the parties, before relying on any summary, including this one.
- Disclosure: whether and when a party or arbitrator should tell others that AI has been used.
- Confidentiality: protecting documents and hearing material when tools send data to third parties.
- Responsibility: counsel remain responsible for submissions whatever tools helped prepare them.
- Decision-making: arbitrators must not delegate their decision to a tool.
- Accuracy: verifying authorities and facts produced with AI help.
- Process: allowing tribunals to give directions on AI use, often early in the case.
Preparing as counsel
Counsel should know, before the first case management conference, what the firm's own policy is and what its tools do with data. A short internal note answering four questions is usually enough: which tools may be used on arbitration matters, what may be entered into them, how outputs are checked, and who decides whether to disclose use.
If the arbitration agreement or the chosen rules say anything about technology or confidentiality, read it. If they are silent, think about whether to propose a short protocol at the first procedural meeting. Agreeing a simple position early, such as that parties will not enter the other side's confidential documents into public tools, avoids argument later.
Checking submissions
The same discipline applies as in litigation. Every authority cited must be found and read. Every quotation must be checked against the source. Every factual statement must be traced to the record. AI can help draft, summarise a bundle or suggest structure, but each assertion must be confirmed by a person.
Arbitral submissions often involve foreign law and unfamiliar authorities, which makes verification harder and more important. If a tool names a decision from a jurisdiction you do not practise in, assume nothing until a local source has been checked.
Considerations for arbitrators
An arbitrator might reasonably use a tool for administrative tasks: sorting documents, producing an index or checking dates in a chronology. Using it to weigh evidence or draft reasoning is a different matter, and the published guidance tends to urge caution. An award is the arbitrator's own work.
A prudent arbitrator would consider telling the parties early what, if anything, they use, and inviting comment. They would also avoid putting confidential material into tools whose data handling they have not checked.
- Use a tool for administrative tasks such as sorting documents or checking dates
- Consider telling the parties early what is used
- Check a tool's data handling before using it
- Use a tool to weigh evidence or draft reasoning
- Put confidential material into tools whose data handling is unchecked
Confidentiality in practice
Confidentiality duties in arbitration come from the agreement, the rules and applicable law, and they differ. Check which apply. Practical steps are the same whatever the source. Use tools with clear terms on how data is stored and whether it is used for training. Limit who can upload hearing bundles. Keep a record of which tools touched which documents. If a protective order or confidentiality agreement covers material, comply with it before using any tool on that material.
A suggested protocol discussion
Suppose a tribunal asks parties for comments on AI use at the first procedural meeting. Counsel might propose that each side states whether it expects to use AI tools to prepare submissions; that neither side enters the other's documents into tools that retain data; that counsel remain responsible for all content; and that the tribunal will tell the parties if it uses a tool for anything beyond administration. None of this is novel. It applies principles that already govern confidentiality and responsibility.
Cost and efficiency arguments
Parties often welcome tools that cut cost, and tribunals are alert to efficiency. That is a fair reason to use AI for document review or for organising a large record. The risk is that cost pressure pushes people to use tools before they have agreed the ground rules. A short conversation early on is cheaper than a satellite dispute over whether a party's use of a tool breached confidentiality.
Counsel should also consider how to explain any use to the client. A client who learns after the event that their sensitive documents passed through a third-party tool will want to know who approved that and on what terms.
Records worth keeping
Keep a short note of the tools used on each arbitration, what was entered into them and who checked the outputs. If a party or tribunal later asks, the note answers the question without anyone relying on memory.
Keeping up
This area is moving. Assign someone at the firm to watch the institutions whose rules you commonly use, and to refresh the internal note when they publish anything new. A thirty-minute review every few months is enough for most practices. Where you work in more than one seat or legal system, check the position in each rather than assuming that guidance in one carries over.
- 1Watch the institutions whose rules you use
- 2Review anything new they have published
- 3Refresh the internal note
- 4Repeat every few months
- Then back to step 1.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
India: arbitration, court intervention and awards, as the law stands in November 2026
The 1996 Act governs Indian arbitration; the Supreme Court has allowed limited modification of awards, and the 2024 amendment Bill is a draft.
6 minute readElectronic evidence under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam
Section 63 of the BSA replaced Section 65B from 1 July 2024, adding a prescribed certificate format, mandatory hash values and an expert co-signature. This article explains every change that matters in practice.
6 minute readAI in Witness Bundle and Proof of Evidence Preparation: What to Automate and What Not To
A practical guide for litigators on which parts of witness bundle and proof of evidence preparation AI can handle, and which parts it must not touch.
6 minute read