Deepfakes and evidence authentication: what litigators should do now
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
A client hands you a voice recording in which the other side seems to admit everything. A witness produces a video that contradicts the pleadings. A year ago you might have asked whether it helped. Now the first question is whether it is real. Cheap tools can fabricate convincing audio, video and images, and they can also give a guilty party a new line of defence: that genuine evidence is fake. Litigators need habits for both directions.
Key points
- Expect disputes about authenticity from both sides: fabricated evidence and claims that real evidence is fake.
- Ask where media came from, secure the original and record who has handled it.
- Treat metadata as a clue, and look for corroboration elsewhere.
- Instruct a forensic expert early if authenticity may be contested, and be wary of detection tools claiming certainty.
Two problems, not one
The obvious risk is fabricated evidence put forward as real. The less discussed risk is the reverse: a party who says that authentic material is a deepfake, hoping to cast doubt. Lawyers may find themselves arguing about authenticity far more often, on both sides of the dispute.
Courts in different places are still working out how to deal with this. Some are considering changes to rules of evidence or to practice directions. Check the guidance from your court, regulator or bar, and watch for new developments in your jurisdiction. This article offers practical questions, not a statement of what any rule requires.
- Fabricated media put forward as real
- Cheap tools make convincing audio, video and images
- A party says authentic material is a deepfake
- The aim is to cast doubt on genuine evidence
Questions to ask when a client gives you media
Start at intake. Many problems can be avoided by asking a few plain questions before the item is relied on.
- Who made this, with what device, and when?
- Where has the original file been since? Who has had access?
- Is this the original, or a copy, a screen recording or a forward through a messaging app?
- Who else was present, and can they speak to it?
- Has it been edited, compressed, cropped or converted in any way?
- Does anything in the content conflict with documents we already hold?
Preserve before you analyse
Treat the original like a physical exhibit. Take a copy for working purposes and keep the original untouched, with a record of how it was obtained and who has handled it. Note the file name, size, dates and the device it came from. Opening and re-saving a file can alter its metadata, so be careful about how it is handled.
Apps often strip information. A video sent through a messaging service may lose the data that would have helped establish where and when it was recorded. If the original device is available, secure it, rather than relying on a forwarded copy.
Metadata and what it can and cannot show
Files often carry information about how and when they were created. That can be useful: a creation date that conflicts with the account, or software signatures that suggest editing. But metadata can be changed or stripped, and its absence does not prove fabrication. It is a clue, not a verdict.
Beyond the file, look for corroboration in the world. Do cell site records, access logs, other photographs or witness evidence match? Evidence that is real tends to leave other traces. A fabricated item often stands alone.
When to bring in an expert
If authenticity may be contested, instruct a forensic specialist early, before the item is central to the case. An expert can examine the file's structure, look for signs of manipulation and explain the limits of what can be known. Be wary of any tool that claims to detect deepfakes with certainty. Detection is an arms race, and results should be treated as one input, interpreted by someone qualified.
Think also about what the expert will need: the original file, device access and the chain of custody. Experts cannot reconstruct a history that nobody recorded.
Challenging the other side's media
- Ask early for the original files in native form, with metadata, not just screenshots or exports.
- Ask for details of the device, the account and the chain of custody.
- Consider whether disclosure or a request for inspection is the right route under your procedure.
- Look for inconsistency between the media and the surrounding evidence.
- Raise authenticity at the right procedural moment. Delay may weaken the point.
Be measured. Alleging fabrication without a basis can damage your credibility. Raise the question when you have a reason, and be ready to explain it.
In criminal and family cases
The stakes are higher where liberty or children are involved. A fabricated recording in a custody dispute, or a manipulated image in a criminal trial, can do grave harm. Defence lawyers should consider challenging the provenance of prosecution media, while recognising that genuine evidence deserves to be treated as such. Family lawyers dealing with threats or abuse often rely on messages and recordings, and clients should be told early to preserve originals and avoid editing or trimming anything.
Advice to give clients now
- Keep original files and devices. Do not trim, filter or forward them for convenience.
- Do not create or share edited material, even as a joke, if a dispute is possible.
- Note when and where recordings are made, and who was there.
- Be honest with us about anything that may have been altered.
- Keep original files and devices
- Note when and where recordings are made, and who was there
- Be honest about anything that may have been altered
- Trim, filter or forward originals for convenience
- Create or share edited material, even as a joke
A note for junior lawyers and paralegals
If you are the person handed a file with a recording on it, speak up early. Ask where it came from and say so if the answer is unclear. Write down what you were given and when. It is far easier to raise a question on day one than to explain on day sixty why nobody asked. Seniors should make it easy to ask, and treat the question as a sign of care rather than of doubt about the client.
What none of this settles
Standards of proof, admissibility and the weight of evidence vary by place and are changing. Technology will move faster than rules. The sound response is the same as for any evidence: ask where it came from, secure the original, seek corroboration and use experts when it matters. A lawyer who builds these habits now will be better placed whichever way the rules develop.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
India: arbitration, court intervention and awards, as the law stands in November 2026
The 1996 Act governs Indian arbitration; the Supreme Court has allowed limited modification of awards, and the 2024 amendment Bill is a draft.
6 minute readElectronic evidence under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam
Section 63 of the BSA replaced Section 65B from 1 July 2024, adding a prescribed certificate format, mandatory hash values and an expert co-signature. This article explains every change that matters in practice.
6 minute readAI in Witness Bundle and Proof of Evidence Preparation: What to Automate and What Not To
A practical guide for litigators on which parts of witness bundle and proof of evidence preparation AI can handle, and which parts it must not touch.
6 minute read