Judges using generative AI: what lawyers should know
By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read
Most discussion of AI in courts concerns what lawyers do wrong: the fabricated citation, the unchecked draft. A second question is less discussed but just as practical. Judges and their staff are also being offered AI tools, and several courts have published guidance on how they may use them. Litigators and advocates should know what that guidance says, because it shapes what a judge will expect of a submission, how carefully citations will be checked and what a judge may say about a party's use of AI.
Key points
- Courts, including those in England and Wales and in Kerala, have published guidance for their own judges and staff; read the current text for your court.
- A theme in published guidance is that the judge stays personally responsible and that private information stays out of public tools.
- Write submissions so that every citation is easy to check: full references, short quotations, one-sentence propositions.
- Check court rules on disclosing AI use, and never state that something was verified when it was not.
Courts are writing guidance for their own judges
In several jurisdictions the judiciary has published guidance for judicial office holders on generative AI. Two examples can be cited from official or well-documented sources. In England and Wales, the Courts and Tribunals Judiciary has published guidance for judicial office holders, the current version dated 31 October 2025, which replaced an April 2025 version. In India, the Kerala High Court issued a policy in July 2025 for its district judiciary.
Other courts have issued, or are preparing, their own material. These documents differ in scope, force and detail, and they change. Before relying on a summary, including this one, read the current text for the court that matters to you.
What the English guidance says, in outline
The judiciary's published page states that the guidance applies to judicial office holders under the Lady Chief Justice and the Senior President of Tribunals, along with their clerks, judicial assistants, legal advisers and other support staff. Among its themes are that use of AI must uphold the integrity of the administration of justice and the rule of law, and that judicial office holders remain personally responsible for material produced in their name.
It also warns that private information should not be entered into public AI tools, that accidental disclosure should be reported as a data incident, and that users should be aware of bias in training data and of the tendency of these systems to produce incorrect or misleading information. For the full text and any later revision, read the guidance on the judiciary's website.
What the Kerala policy says, in outline
As reported, the Kerala High Court policy applies to members of the State's district judiciary and the employees who assist them. Its central point is that AI tools must not be used in place of decision-making or legal reasoning. Judicial officers and staff are expected to take part in training.
The common thread with the English guidance is accountability. Whatever help a judge takes with administrative or background tasks, the decision and its reasons remain the judge's own.
What this means for how you write submissions
If a judge is wary of AI-generated error, then the cost of a bad citation in your submission rises. A judge who finds one authority that does not exist, or a quotation that does not match, will reasonably doubt the rest of the document. Write with that reader in mind.
- Give full citations to recognised reports, with pinpoint references to the passages relied on.
- Quote from the source, and keep quotations short enough for the judge to check at a glance.
- State the proposition each authority supports in a sentence, so that a mismatch is easy to see.
- Make sure every authority has been opened and read by someone on your team.
- Avoid long strings of authorities for a simple point; give the best one or two.
- Provide copies of unreported or less accessible authorities with the bundle.
- Give full citations with pinpoint references
- Keep quotations short enough to check at a glance
- State the proposition each authority supports
- Make sure every authority has been opened and read
- String together many authorities for a simple point
- State that something was verified when it was not
Disclosing your own use of AI
Courts differ on whether and how lawyers should say that AI was used in preparing a document. Some have issued practice directions or standing orders, some have not. The guidance for judges, as published, includes the idea that litigants are responsible for what they present to the court, whatever tool produced it.
Check the rules of each court you appear in, and the guidance from your regulator or bar. If there is a requirement, comply exactly. If there is none, think about whether a short statement of verification is wise in a document where the court might wonder. Whatever you do, never say that something has been checked when it has not.
What a judge using AI may mean for you
Published guidance generally treats administrative help differently from the core task of deciding. A judge might use a tool to summarise a long document, to locate a passage or to tidy a draft of a procedural direction. That means your documents may be read in part through a summary.
That is a reason to write clearly and to put the key point at the top of each section, with the supporting paragraph references below. A document that is easy to summarise accurately is a document less likely to be misread, by a person or a machine. It also argues for careful headings and a short, accurate summary of argument at the start.
Confidentiality and other people's material
The guidance on judges also stresses care with private information. Apply the same thinking at your end. When you prepare for a hearing, you handle material that is confidential, sometimes under court orders or restrictions. Do not paste it into a public tool. Check where any tool sends text and how it is handled.
Note, too, that a court may ask how a document was prepared if something looks wrong. A short internal note of how citations were verified costs a few minutes and may save a difficult exchange at a hearing.
Staying current
Treat this as a moving area. Check the websites of the courts where you appear for new guidance, practice directions and notices. Ask court staff if you are unsure. Put a note in the firm's litigation checklist to look for AI-related directions at the start of each matter. A few minutes at the outset is cheap compared with a surprise at the hearing.
Sources
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
India: arbitration, court intervention and awards, as the law stands in November 2026
The 1996 Act governs Indian arbitration; the Supreme Court has allowed limited modification of awards, and the 2024 amendment Bill is a draft.
6 minute readElectronic evidence under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam
Section 63 of the BSA replaced Section 65B from 1 July 2024, adding a prescribed certificate format, mandatory hash values and an expert co-signature. This article explains every change that matters in practice.
6 minute readAI in Witness Bundle and Proof of Evidence Preparation: What to Automate and What Not To
A practical guide for litigators on which parts of witness bundle and proof of evidence preparation AI can handle, and which parts it must not touch.
6 minute read