US: court standing orders on AI disclosure and certification
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
A litigator in the United States preparing a filing may need to check more than the local rules. Some individual judges have issued standing orders about generative AI, and no two are quite alike. One asks for disclosure. Another asks for a certificate that citations have been verified. A third says nothing. Since a mistake can mean a sanction or a strike, the sensible response is a tracking habit, not a guess.
Key points
- AI-related standing orders differ by court and by judge, and they change, so check the current text for each case.
- Read the order's definition of AI and what it requires: disclosure, certification, restriction or reminder.
- Build a case-by-case tracker and a pre-filing check into the firm's routine.
- Make any certification true by opening and reading every authority, and record who did it.
- Existing duties of competence and candour apply whether or not an order exists.
Why the orders vary
The United States has a federal system and many courts: federal district and appellate courts, state trial and appellate courts, and specialised tribunals. Within a single court, individual judges often have their own standing orders or procedures that supplement the local rules. These cover matters such as page limits, motions practice and now, in some courts, the use of AI.
Do not assume that one rule on how lawyers disclose or certify their use of AI in filings applies everywhere. Approaches can differ between courts and between judges in the same court, and the position changes, so treat any list as out of date and look at the current sources for the court in question. This article does not catalogue particular orders for that reason.
What orders typically ask for
Without suggesting that any particular judge requires any particular thing, standing orders on this subject tend to fall into a few families. Read the actual wording that applies to your case, since small differences matter.
- A requirement to disclose whether generative AI was used in preparing a filing, sometimes only if it was used to draft substantive text.
- A certification that a person has checked every citation and quotation for accuracy.
- A statement that lawyers remain responsible for the content of filings, whatever tools were used.
- A prohibition or restriction on using AI to produce certain documents, or on submitting AI-generated content without review.
- A reminder of existing duties, such as accuracy and candour to the tribunal, without any new disclosure rule.
Read the definition carefully
The word AI covers a lot. Some orders speak of generative AI, some of any artificial intelligence, and some name particular products. A broad wording could catch spell-checkers, grammar tools, research platforms with AI features or translation software, while a narrow one might not. Look at what is defined, what is excluded and what the order says about research tools that you already use.
If it is unclear, ask. Many chambers have a procedure for questions to the clerk or a law clerk, and a short and polite enquiry is better than a wrong assumption. Record any answer you receive.
How to find the orders that apply
Build a checking step into the start of every case and repeat it before each significant filing. Orders can be issued or changed during a case.
- 1
Check the court's website for general orders, local rules and the individual judge's procedures or standing orders.
- 2
Read the scheduling order and any case management order in the case.
- 3
Look at the docket for any order issued in the case about technology or filings.
- 4
Check any magistrate judge's procedures, since they may differ from the district judge's.
- 5
Ask the clerk's office where it is unclear where to find an order.
- 6
Record the date on which you checked, and what you found.
- 1Check the court's rules and the judge's procedures
- 2Read the scheduling and case management orders
- 3Look at the docket for any order on technology
- 4Record the date you checked and what you found
- 5Repeat before each significant filing
- Then back to step 1.
Tracking across a docket of cases
A firm with many cases before many judges needs a system. A shared sheet can list, for each case, the court, the judge, any AI-related order and its date, the requirement and who is responsible for compliance. Add a reminder to check for changes before major filings.
Put the requirement in the filing checklist for the case so that the person assembling the filing sees it. If a certificate is required, prepare the wording in advance. If the order requires disclosure, decide the firm's position on what counts as use and apply it consistently.
Complying honestly and consistently
Where a certification is needed, make sure that it is true. That means a real check, not a signature on trust. Open each authority, read it, and confirm that it supports the proposition. Keep a record of who did that and when. If an error is found after filing, correct it promptly and tell the court as the circumstances require. Check the guidance from your state bar and the rules that bind you for the duties that apply.
Where disclosure is required, describe the use accurately and briefly, without exaggeration or concealment. If the firm has a policy on tools, make sure it matches what you tell the court.
- Make any certification true through a real check
- Open each authority and read it
- Describe any use accurately and briefly
- Make sure the firm's policy matches what you tell the court
- Sign a certificate on trust
- Exaggerate or conceal the use of a tool
A hypothetical week in a litigation team
Suppose a five-lawyer team has matters before three judges. On Monday a paralegal checks each judge's page and finds that one has a procedure about generative AI and the others say nothing. She adds a line to the tracker and a certificate template to that case's folder. On Thursday the associate preparing a brief for that judge opens every cited case, ticks them off on a list and signs the internal record. The partner reads the certificate wording against the order before approving the filing. Nothing here is complicated, and every step can be shown later.
Beyond the orders: the duties you already have
Even where no order applies, existing duties of competence, candour to the tribunal and supervision are engaged when AI is used. Unchecked AI output in a filing is a risk under those duties whether or not a specific AI order applies, and your state bar and court rules say what follows from a failure. The practical conclusion is the same in every court: verify everything, and do not let a tool's fluency stand in for your own reading.
Bar associations and state courts have also been publishing guidance on this subject. Look for what your state bar says, and treat it as a starting point for the firm's own policy.
A short checklist for each filing
Before filing, ask: have I checked the court's rules and the judge's procedures today? Is there an order on AI in this case? Does it require disclosure or a certificate? Has every citation been opened and read by a person? Does the firm's record show who checked? If any answer is no, hold the filing until it is yes.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Generative AI guidance for lawyers: how six markets compare
How to find what regulators, courts and bar bodies have said in six markets, and the common themes across them.
5 minute readUS: ABA Formal Opinion 512 on generative AI, in plain language
What the American Bar Association's first ethics opinion on generative AI covers, topic by topic.
4 minute readEU AI Act: what it means for firms outside the EU with EU clients
How a firm outside the EU should think about the EU AI Act when it works for European clients.
5 minute read