E-signatures for client onboarding: what to check
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
A new client is keen to start. You send an engagement letter as a PDF, ask them to print it, sign it, scan it and send it back. Three days later you are still waiting, and the client has not been billed for the work you have already begun. Electronic signing removes most of that delay. It also raises questions that a printer never did. Who actually signed? What proof would you have if the client later said they had not? And is this the kind of document that can be signed on a screen at all?
Key points
- Sort your documents into those that can be signed electronically, those that depend on a third party and those that need wet ink.
- Choose a process that records who signed, when, and a fingerprint of exactly what they signed.
- Test the signing journey on your own phone before clients use it.
- A signature is not an identity check. Do know-your-client steps separately.
Start with the document, not the tool
Electronic signing is not one thing. At one end sits a typed name or a tick in a box. At the other sit signatures backed by a certificate issued to a verified identity. Different places treat these differently, and the same place may treat different documents differently.
An engagement letter or client care letter is usually a contract between the firm and the client. For most firms it is the easiest document to sign electronically, because the stakes of a dispute about the signature are modest. Other documents are another matter. Wills, deeds, some property transfers, powers of attorney and certain family documents often carry formal requirements about witnesses, notaries or original paper. Those rules are set locally and change over time. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar, and the rules for the specific document, before you assume a screen will do.
A short sorting exercise for your document types
Sit down once with your practice areas and sort every document you send for signature into three piles. Do this with a senior lawyer, not alone, and write the result down.
- Pile one: documents where an electronic signature is plainly acceptable, such as engagement letters, terms of business, client authorities to obtain records and consent forms for the firm's own use.
- Pile two: documents where it depends on the counterparty, the court, a registry or a bank. Ask them what they accept and keep their answer on file.
- Pile three: documents that need wet ink, witnesses or a notary. Plan the logistics for these and do not let a sign-up tool tempt anyone to shortcut them.
What evidence a signature should leave
If a signature is ever challenged, you want to show who was asked to sign, that they saw the document, what exactly they signed and when. A good process leaves a trail without anyone having to remember to build one.
Look for these items in whatever tool you use:
- The identity the signer used, such as the email address or mobile number the link was sent to.
- The time of signing, and ideally the time the link was opened.
- The network address from which they signed.
- A fingerprint of the document, so you can show that the signed version is the one that was sent and has not been altered since.
- A final signed copy that includes a page recording these details, stored with the matter.
Signing on a phone
Many clients will sign on a phone, on a train or in a car park. That is a good thing, as long as the experience is built for it. Open the signing link on your own phone before you send it to anyone. Can you read the whole letter without pinching and scrolling sideways? Is the signing step obvious? Does it work without installing an app or creating an account?
Every extra hurdle costs you a client who gives up or phones the office. Equally, a link that anyone who forwards the email can use is a weakness. Prefer a link that is unique to one signer and shows only that one document, so a person cannot wander into anything else.
- Open the signing link on your own phone before you send it
- Check the whole letter reads without pinching or scrolling sideways
- Let the client sign without installing an app or creating an account
- Use a link unique to one signer that shows only that one document
- Add extra hurdles that make a client give up or phone the office
- Send a link that anyone who forwards the email can use
Identity: signing is not the same as knowing who is signing
An electronic signature proves that someone with access to a particular inbox or phone clicked and typed a name. It does not prove that person is who they say they are. Anti-money-laundering and know-your-client checks are separate duties, and they sit outside the signature step.
In practice, many firms confirm identity in a call or meeting first, then send the letter to the contact details they confirmed. If the client is a company, record who has authority to sign for it. A letter signed by a junior employee with no authority is a weak foundation for a long engagement.
- Someone with access to a particular inbox or phone clicked
- That person typed a name
- That the person is who they say they are
- That anti-money-laundering and know-your-client checks were done
Counter-signing and keeping the record
Decide who signs for the firm and when. Some firms treat the engagement as accepted when the client signs and the work begins. Others want a partner to counter-sign first. Either is workable. What matters is that everyone knows which applies, and that no billable work starts on an unsigned letter by accident.
File the signed copy on the matter itself, not in a personal inbox. Note the date it was signed in the matter record so that a conflicts or compliance review can find it without opening the PDF.
Questions to ask any e-signature provider
- Where is signed data stored, and in which country?
- What does the signature record, and can I export that record with the document?
- Can a client sign without creating an account?
- Can I stop a link being used after it has been sent in error?
- How long are signed documents kept, and can I get them out if I leave?
- Does it claim to meet a particular legal standard of signature, and does the vendor say plainly which documents it is not suitable for?
The last question is the most revealing. A vendor that states its limits is easier to trust than one that says everything is valid everywhere.
Where e-signing does not help
A clean signing process does not make a poor engagement letter good. It will not fix unclear scope, missing fee information or a client who did not understand what they agreed to. It also does not remove your duty to explain terms. Suppose a sole practitioner sends the letter and the client signs within a minute, on a phone, without scrolling. The record shows a signature. It does not show understanding. A short call before sending is still worth making for anything complex.
Engagement letters in ChamberOne
- Draft from your own templates with the matter's details filled in, and export to Word.
- Send the engagement letter to the client for signature on their phone.
- The client types their name on a page that shows only that document.
- You get a signed PDF with a certificate page, and the firm can counter-sign.
- Click-to-sign records the typed name, the time, the IP address and the document's fingerprint.
What it does not do
- Click-to-sign is a simple electronic signature. It is not a certificate-based or qualified electronic signature.
- Some documents, such as deeds and wills, need formalities that an electronic signature does not meet. Check the rules for your document before you use it.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
AI and access to justice: an honest assessment
Where AI can lower the cost of routine legal help, where it cannot replace advice, and who bears the risk when it is wrong.
5 minute readClient portals: what self-service does for clients and the firm
Which questions a portal answers, what to keep out of it, and how it reduces routine calls.
5 minute readAI chatbots on law firm websites: benefits, risks and rules
A chatbot can help with intake, but it can also say too much. Decide its limits before it goes live.
4 minute read