ChamberOne

One platform or many tools: consolidating legal technology

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Walk around a typical small firm and count the logins. Email, a document store, a practice system, an accounting package, an e-signature service, a time recorder, a research subscription, a dictation app, and now an AI assistant or two. Each was a sensible purchase on its day. Together they make a pile of tools that do not talk to each other. The question for a firm leader is whether to bring them together, and how far to go.

Key points

  • First find out what tools are in use, including the unofficial ones, and what each costs and holds.
  • Consolidation brings simpler security, fewer silos and clearer cost; best-of-breed brings depth and flexibility.
  • Count an integration as a risk unless a named person owns it.
  • Check export and exit terms before you commit to any platform.

How firms end up with so many tools

Few firms choose sprawl on purpose. A partner finds a tool for a problem. A department buys its own. A trial becomes permanent. Over several years, nobody owns the whole picture, and the real cost of the collection, in licences, training, integration work and risk, is hard to see.

AI has made this worse. Because it is easy to try, people sign up for assistants on their own, paste in client material and never tell anyone. Whatever you decide on consolidation, you need to know what is already in use.

The case for fewer tools

  • One place for the facts. When matter details, documents, time and billing sit in one system, nobody retypes, and fewer errors creep in.
  • Fewer data silos. A search or an AI question can see the whole matter, not just the part held in one product.
  • Simpler security. One set of permissions, one sign-in method, one audit log and one vendor to assess.
  • Easier training. New staff learn one system and a single way of working.
  • Clearer costs. One subscription is simpler to budget and to compare year on year.

The case for best-of-breed

  • Depth. A specialist tool for, say, contract analysis or e-discovery may do a narrow job better than a general platform.
  • Flexibility. You can replace one piece without disturbing the rest.
  • Less lock-in to a single vendor's pace of development.
  • Fit with existing habits. If your people are fond of a tool that works, replacing it has a human cost.

The honest answer is that both cases are strong. The right mix depends on the firm, which is why this is a decision to work through, not a slogan to adopt.

Fewer tools
  • One place for the facts
  • Fewer data silos
  • Simpler security
  • Easier training
  • Clearer costs
Best-of-breed
  • Depth in a narrow job
  • Flexibility to replace one piece
  • Less lock-in to one vendor's pace
  • Fits habits people already like
Fewer tools or best-of-breed

What integration really costs

Vendors of separate tools will often say they integrate. Look closely at what that means. Does data flow both ways, or only one? Is it in real time or overnight? Who fixes it when it breaks, and how fast? A thin connection that copies a client name but not the documents or the time entries still leaves your staff doing double entry.

Integrations also age. When either vendor changes its product, the link can fail silently. Someone in the firm has to own each integration and check it still works. If you cannot name that person, count the integration as a risk.

Security and confidentiality across many vendors

Every extra tool is another place client information lives. Each has its own sign-in, its own admin settings, its own retention rules and its own sub-processors. A leaver may be removed from five systems and left in a sixth. A restricted matter may be hidden in the practice system and wide open in the document store.

Consolidation does not make security automatic, but it reduces the number of places you must get right. If you keep several tools, make sure access is controlled centrally where possible, that you can see who did what in each, and that restricted matters stay restricted everywhere.

A decision guide

Work through these steps with your partners and practice manager. They are in order for a reason.

  1. 1

    List every tool in use, including the unofficial ones. Ask staff directly and promise no blame.

  2. 2

    For each, note what it costs, who uses it, what data it holds and what it connects to.

  3. 3

    Mark what is essential, what overlaps with another tool and what nobody would miss.

  4. 4

    Decide your core: the system that holds matters, clients, documents, time and billing.

  5. 5

    For each remaining tool, ask whether the core can do the job well enough. If yes, plan to retire it.

  6. 6

    Where a specialist tool does clearly better work, keep it, and write down how it connects to the core and who owns that link.

  7. 7

    Check exit terms before you commit: can you export all your data in a usable form, and how long does it take?

Switching risk and timing

Moving to a platform is disruptive. Data has to be migrated, people retrained and old habits broken. Do not start in the middle of year-end, a major trial, or a period when key staff are on leave. Run the old and new in parallel for a short period, with a clear cut-off date. Migrate a small practice area first and learn from it.

Test your exit before you need it. Ask the vendor, in writing, how you would get your data out and in what format. A platform you cannot leave is a risk, however good it is today.

Questions to ask a platform vendor

  • What parts of the product are built and in use today, and what is only on a roadmap?
  • What can I export, in what format and how quickly?
  • How do AI features work, which models are used, and can we switch them off?
  • How are permissions handled across matters and clients?
  • What happens to our data if you are sold or close down?

Treat 'on the roadmap' as 'not available' when you compare options. Decide on what you can use now.

Ask for a trial on your own documents, not a demonstration on the vendor's. A demonstration shows the product at its best. A trial with your real files and your real staff shows how it behaves on an ordinary Tuesday.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

One platform or many tools: legal technology choices