ChamberOne

Online dispute resolution and AI in courts: what is real so far

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Headlines about 'robot judges' and 'AI courts' appear every few months. Most of them describe something far more modest than the headline suggests, and some describe nothing that exists. Meanwhile, quieter and more practical digital changes have reached a good many courts and tribunals. For litigators, the useful question is which changes affect how you work now.

Key points

  • Separate digital court administration, online dispute resolution and AI decision support; they are different things.
  • Most AI in courts is assistive, with a human responsible for the decision.
  • Judge any new project by whether it is live, who runs it and what the official source says.
  • Learn each court's digital procedures and practice directions, and prepare clients for remote hearings.

Three things that get lumped together

Discussion of technology in courts mixes up several different ideas. Pulling them apart makes the picture clearer.

  • Digital court administration: online filing, electronic case files, remote hearings, e-bundles and online portals. This is the most widespread and the least dramatic.
  • Online dispute resolution, or ODR: a process for resolving a dispute online, often through a platform that guides the parties through exchange of information, negotiation and, if that fails, a decision by a person.
  • Automated or AI-assisted decision support: tools that help staff or judges with tasks such as sorting cases, finding authorities or summarising documents. It is a much rarer thing and less settled.

What online dispute resolution means in practice

In its practical form, ODR is mostly a better way of doing what small-claims processes already do. A claimant describes the problem and uploads evidence through a web form. The other side responds. The platform may offer a space for negotiation, and a mediator or a decision-maker steps in when needed. The advantage is convenience: no travel, flexible timing and clearer steps.

Different places have adopted different models, and some are run by courts, some by tribunals and some by private providers. Because the details change and vary between jurisdictions, check the official site of the court or tribunal you are dealing with, rather than relying on a general description.

Where AI actually appears

Where AI is used in this setting, it is usually in support roles. Examples include helping users complete forms, translating or transcribing, sorting incoming documents, and suggesting where to find information. These are tasks where a mistake can be caught and where a human remains responsible for the outcome.

The idea of AI deciding a contested case is a different matter. It raises questions of fairness, transparency, bias, appeal rights and public confidence that courts are cautious about. Treat claims that a court has handed decisions to an algorithm with scepticism until you have seen the court's own description of what is done.

Support roles
  • Helping users complete forms
  • Translating or transcribing
  • Sorting incoming documents
  • A human remains responsible
Deciding a contested case
  • Raises questions of fairness and bias
  • Raises transparency and appeal rights
  • Courts are cautious
  • Treat such claims with scepticism
AI in courts: support or decision

How to tell hype from a working system

When you read about a new digital justice project, a few questions help.

  1. 1

    Is it in use for real cases, or is it a pilot, a proposal or a prototype?

  2. 2

    Who runs it: the court, a government department or a private company?

  3. 3

    What exactly does the technology do, and who makes the final decision?

  4. 4

    Is there a published evaluation, and who carried it out?

  5. 5

    Is the source an official court page, or a news article or vendor brochure?

  6. 6

    Can the parties appeal or ask for a human to review the outcome?

What this means for small claims and low-value disputes

The strongest case for digital tools is in low-value disputes, where the cost and delay of traditional proceedings can exceed what is in dispute. Online processes can lower that barrier, particularly for people who cannot easily take time off work or travel to a court building.

There are risks too. People without good internet access, devices or confidence with technology may be left out. Self-represented parties may not understand a platform's choices. A process that is easy to start may also encourage claims that would not otherwise be brought. Whether a given system achieves a fair balance is an empirical question, and one that policy-minded lawyers should watch with care.

What litigators should do now

  • Learn the digital procedures of the courts where you appear: how to file, how to serve, how to attend remotely and how to prepare electronic bundles.
  • Read each court's practice directions on technology, including any on the use of AI in preparing documents. They differ between courts.
  • Prepare clients for online hearings: connection, documents to hand, a quiet room and how to behave on camera.
  • Treat remote advocacy as a skill. Eye contact, pace and handling documents on screen all differ from a courtroom.
  • Keep a record of each filing and each confirmation from the court's system.

Access to justice cuts both ways

Technology can widen access if it is designed with users in mind. It can narrow it if it assumes everyone is online. Lawyers who advise community organisations, legal aid providers or small businesses are well placed to say what works. Feedback to courts and policy bodies, offered constructively and with examples, is one of the most useful contributions the profession can make.

It is also reasonable to ask for transparency. If a court uses a tool that affects how cases are managed, parties and lawyers can fairly expect to be told what it is for and what it is not for.

The sensible position for now

Digital court processes are real and growing. AI inside them is mostly assistive and carefully limited. Predictions of AI judges are mostly speculation. A practical litigator can ignore the speculation, master the digital procedures that already exist, and watch official announcements for anything that changes the rules of the game in a court where they practise.

A good internal habit is a short note, shared every quarter, listing the digital changes in the courts where your firm appears most. One person can keep it, drawing only on official court notices. It stops the firm learning about a new filing requirement from a rejected document, and it gives the partners a factual basis for discussing what to adopt.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Online dispute resolution and AI in courts: what is real