Senior lawyers learning AI without embarrassment
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
A partner with thirty years of experience does not want to ask a trainee what a prompt is, in front of the team. That reluctance is human, and it is costing firms. The people with the most judgement about what a good legal document looks like are the ones best placed to spot a bad AI draft, but only if they are comfortable enough to use the tools and look closely at the output.
Key points
- Experience in judging legal work is the main asset when reviewing AI output.
- Practise privately on tasks you can judge easily, using only material that is safe to share.
- Reverse mentoring works when sessions are short, confidential and unassessed.
- Provide a named person or drop-in hour for basic questions.
- Learn the failure modes first, and write down your own personal rules.
Why seniority is an asset here, not an obstacle
Reviewing AI output is mainly a matter of knowing what right looks like. A senior lawyer can read a draft indemnity and sense that something is missing, or read a case summary and feel that the holding has been stated too broadly. That instinct is exactly what these tools need around them.
What many senior lawyers lack is not judgement but mechanics: how to phrase a request, how to attach a document, what the tool does with it. Mechanics can be learned in a few sessions. Judgement cannot be taught in a few sessions, which is why the investment should flow towards making senior people comfortable rather than replacing them.
Practise privately, on your own files
Generic training exercises are dull and feel remote. Far better is to take a document you know well, perhaps an old matter with details removed or a published precedent, and ask the tool to do something you can judge easily. Summarise this. List the obligations of each party. Rewrite this clause in plain English. You will know within a minute whether it did it well.
Do this alone first, or with one trusted person. The aim is to make your early mistakes in private. Use only material that is safe to put into the tool. If you are unsure whether a tool is approved for client documents, ask the person who looks after the firm's technology and security before you paste anything real.
- Choose a task you could do in your sleep.
- Ask for the output in a form you can compare, such as a table or short list.
- Note what it got right, what it missed and what it invented.
- Repeat with a slightly harder task the next day.
- 1Choose a task you could do in your sleep
- 2Ask for output you can compare, such as a table
- 3Note what it got right, missed and invented
- 4Repeat with a slightly harder task
- Then back to step 1.
Try reverse mentoring, with ground rules
Pair a senior lawyer with a junior colleague who uses the tools comfortably. The junior shows the mechanics; the senior shows how to test the result and what a client or court would care about. Both leave with something. The junior learns what real checking looks like, which is a skill many trainees have not been taught.
Make it work by agreeing a few things at the start. Meet on a fixed schedule, for a short time, in a private room. Nobody reports back to others on what was asked. The junior is not assessed on how well they teach. And the senior is free to say 'start again, I did not follow that' without it going any further.
Make a safe place for basic questions
Embarrassment lives in public settings. Give people somewhere else to ask. A named person, such as the practice manager or a knowledge lawyer, can be the contact for 'silly' questions by phone or message. Some firms set up a short drop-in hour where people can bring a laptop and a problem.
A short written glossary helps too. Explain in a few lines what a prompt is, what it means to say a tool hallucinates, why the same question can get different answers, and what happens to text you enter. Plain definitions, written without condescension, remove many of the small obstacles that make people feel behind.
Learn the risks before the features
A senior lawyer who knows the failure modes is safer than a junior who knows the shortcuts. Spend one session on what goes wrong: invented citations, confident errors, text quietly changed during editing, and confidential material going somewhere it should not. See each in action on a harmless example.
Then agree your own personal rules. For example: I will never file anything containing an authority I have not opened. I will not paste client names into a tool that the firm has not approved. I will read the whole draft, not just the part the tool flagged. Written rules make you feel in control rather than exposed.
For sole practitioners with nobody to ask
If you work alone, there is no junior to pair with, and nobody to cover for you. Use one tool for one recurring task, such as tidying your attendance notes, and stay with it for a month before adding another. Ask a colleague at another firm or a bar or law society peer group to compare notes now and then.
Check any tool's terms on what happens to the text you enter before using it with client material. If the answer is unclear, treat it as unsuitable for client files. Look at the guidance from your regulator or bar, which many now publish on this subject.
What to do when you feel behind
Almost everyone feels behind at some point, including people who seem fluent. Tools change every few months, and anyone claiming to know all of them is overstating. You do not need to follow every release. You need to know one tool well enough to judge its output and to explain your own rules to others.
If a colleague teases you, answer with a real question about how they check output. That turns the conversation from who is fastest to who is most careful, which is a contest a senior lawyer usually wins.
A realistic first month
Week one: three private sessions of half an hour on old documents. Week two: one reverse mentoring session and a written list of rules. Week three: use the tool on one low-risk live task, such as a summary of a long email chain, and check every line. Week four: sit down and decide what the tool is good for in your practice and what it is not.
By then you will have an opinion earned from experience. That opinion, from someone with your depth, is more valuable to your firm than any vendor demonstration.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Training junior lawyers when AI does the first draft
If routine drafting shrinks, juniors need other ways to build judgment. Practical exercises that keep the learning in the work.
5 minute readThe skills lawyers need to work well with AI
Verification, precise instruction, source reading and client judgment: what to practise and how.
5 minute readLaw students and AI: learning to think before you prompt
AI can be a sparring partner for a law student, but only if you do the thinking first.
4 minute read