ChamberOne

Client money and trust accounts: what automation can and cannot check

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Few parts of a law firm's work are as unforgiving as client money. A small error that goes unnoticed for months can become a regulatory matter, and the people who bear the cost are clients. Reconciliation is the discipline that catches the error early. It is repetitive, precise work, and for that reason software is good at much of it. It is not good at all of it, and the part it cannot do is the part regulators care about most.

Key points

  • A three-way reconciliation compares the bank, the firm's cash record and the sum of client ledgers, and explains every difference.
  • Software is good at ledgers, matching, arithmetic and exception reports.
  • A person must decide whether money is client money, whether a payment is allowed and what an exception means.
  • Real sign-off by a named reviewer, recorded each month, is the control that matters most.

What reconciliation is for

Client money belongs to someone else. A firm holds it in a designated account and must be able to show, at any time, whose it is and how much. Reconciliation is the regular check that the records tell the same story as the bank.

The detailed requirements differ between places and regulators, including how often to reconcile, who must review and what must be kept. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar for your own rules. What follows is a general picture of the work and how software fits.

The idea behind a three-way check

In general terms, a three-way reconciliation compares three views of the same money. The first is the bank's record of the account. The second is the firm's own cash record of what went in and out. The third is the sum of the individual client ledgers, which should add up to the same total. If all three agree, or the differences are fully explained by items in transit, the account is in order. If not, something needs finding.

Different regulators describe the exact records differently, so use the terms and steps your own rules use. The principle is constant: independent records, compared often, with every difference explained.

What software does well

  • Keeps a ledger for each client and matter, so every receipt and payment is posted to a named client.
  • Refuses or warns about postings that would take a client's ledger below zero, where that rule applies.
  • Matches bank lines to ledger entries and highlights the ones that do not match.
  • Calculates totals and differences without arithmetic slips.
  • Produces an exception report: unmatched items, old unpresented cheques, dormant balances, unusual transfers.
  • Keeps a timestamped record of who posted and who approved each entry.

These are exactly the tasks that people do poorly when tired, and software does without complaint. A monthly reconciliation that once took a day can shrink to an hour of reviewing exceptions.

What software cannot decide

A system can tell you that a payment has no matching ledger entry. It cannot tell you why. Was it a client's deposit posted to the wrong matter, a fee transferred before the bill was delivered, or something worse? Someone must investigate and decide.

Software also cannot decide whether a particular receipt is client money in the first place, whether a payment is permitted under the rules, or whether a transfer to the office account is justified. Those are judgments about the nature of the money and the firm's entitlement. Rules on what may be paid from client money, and when, vary, and a ledger that accepts a posting has not approved it.

Software does well
  • Keeps a ledger for each client and matter
  • Warns about postings that would overdraw a ledger
  • Matches bank lines and highlights those that do not match
  • Produces an exception report
A person must decide
  • Why a payment has no matching entry
  • Whether a receipt is client money
  • Whether a payment is permitted under the rules
  • Whether a transfer to the office account is justified
Software and people in client money checks

Where a person must sign off

Treat sign-off as a real act. The person reviewing the reconciliation should read the exception report, ask about each item, and sign a statement that the three records agree and that differences are explained. Many regulators expect a responsible person to be named. Check who that must be in your market.

  • A named reviewer who is not the person who posted the entries, where staffing allows.
  • A dated sign-off recorded with the reconciliation.
  • A written note on each exception and what was done about it.
  • Escalation to the partner or compliance officer for anything unresolved after a set number of days.

Where AI fits, if at all

AI tools can help read bank statements in odd formats, suggest likely matches for unmatched lines or draft an explanation of an exception. These are conveniences. For the reconciliation itself, deterministic rules are the right tool: the sums must be the same every time, and a model that estimates is not what you want in a ledger.

If you use AI to propose matches, treat the proposals as unconfirmed until a person has verified them against the underlying records. Keep the AI steps separate from the ledger, so that nothing posts without review.

A monthly routine

  1. 1

    Import or enter bank data for the period and match it to ledger entries.

  2. 2

    Investigate every unmatched item before moving on.

  3. 3

    Confirm that no client ledger is overdrawn and that dormant balances are noted.

  4. 4

    Compare the three totals and record any differences and their causes.

  5. 5

    The reviewer reads the exception report and signs.

  6. 6

    File the reconciliation, the exception notes and the sign-off together.

  1. 1Import bank data and match it to ledger entries
  2. 2Investigate every unmatched item
  3. 3Confirm no client ledger is overdrawn
  4. 4Compare the three totals and record differences
  5. 5Reviewer reads the exception report and signs
  6. 6File the reconciliation, notes and sign-off together
  7. Then back to step 1.
The monthly reconciliation routine

Small firms and sole practitioners

If you are a sole practitioner, you may be both the person who posts and the person who reviews. Regulators generally understand that, but it raises the risk of a mistake going unseen. Consider asking an accountant, a colleague at another firm or an outside bookkeeper to review a sample each quarter, and keep a note of what they found. Even a light second look is far better than none, and it gives you something to show if you are ever asked.

Questions to ask a software vendor

  • Does the system keep a separate ledger per client and matter?
  • What stops a ledger going negative, and can it be overridden?
  • What does the exception report show?
  • Is every posting and approval recorded with who and when?
  • Has the system been assessed against our regulator's accounts rules, or does it make no such claim?

Treat the last answer carefully. Software supports good practice. It does not by itself make a firm compliant, and a vendor who says otherwise should be questioned.

Client money in ChamberOne

  • Keep client money on a trust ledger with three-way reconciliation.
  • Record time, apply rate cards, fixed fees, per-appearance fees or milestones, and put the invoice through approval.
  • Every read and write is recorded automatically with who, when, IP address and before and after values.

What it does not do

  • The client-money ledger has not been assessed against any professional accounts rules. It does not by itself make a firm compliant with them.
  • It does not decide whether money is client money or whether a payment is permitted. A person reviews and signs off.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Trust account reconciliation: what software can check