Conflict checks for small law firms: a procedure you can actually follow
By the ChamberOne teamUpdated 6 minute read
Large firms have a conflicts department. A small firm has a partner who remembers most of the clients. That works until the firm takes on its third lawyer, or until the one matter nobody remembered. This guide describes a procedure small enough to follow on every new instruction. It covers the mechanics of checking; whether a particular situation is a conflict, and what to do about it, is decided by the professional rules that apply to you.
Why memory stops working
Memory fails in predictable ways. It does not cover matters handled by a colleague, clients from before a lawyer joined, parties who were on the other side, or companies that have since changed their name. It also cannot be shown to anyone: if a question is raised later, "we would have remembered" is not a record.
Keep one list of everyone the firm has dealt with
A check is only as good as the list it is run against. The firm needs a single record that includes more than its clients.
- Every client, current and former.
- Opposing parties in every matter.
- Related people and companies: directors, shareholders, guarantors, spouses, parent and subsidiary companies.
- Former names and trading names.
- People who made an enquiry and shared confidential details, even if the firm never acted.
When to check
- At the first enquiry, before confidential detail is taken. A name search at this stage takes a minute and avoids hearing something you should not have heard.
- Before the matter is opened, once you know all the parties.
- Whenever a party is added or changes: a new defendant, a new buyer, a guarantor.
- When a lawyer joins the firm, against the matters they bring with them or worked on before.
What to search
Search every party to the new matter against the whole list, not only the prospective client against existing clients.
- Search the name in the forms it could have been recorded in: with and without initials, with the family name first, and in other languages or scripts if your clients use them.
- Search companies by registration number as well as by name. Names change; numbers do not.
- Search identity numbers where you hold them. Two people can share a name.
- Search the people behind a company, not only the company.
Read the hits; do not just count them
A search produces possible matches, and most are harmless: a common surname, a bank that appears in half the firm's matters. Someone has to read each one and decide. In a small firm that should be a partner, or the lawyer taking the matter with a second lawyer reviewing anything doubtful.
The decision belongs to a lawyer applying the professional rules of your jurisdiction. The procedure's job is to make sure the question is asked every time and the information needed to answer it is in front of the right person.
Record the result, including a clear one
For every new matter, keep a short record: who was searched, on what date, by whom, what came up, and what was decided. A check that found nothing is still recorded. If the same question comes back in three years, the record shows the check was done and what was known at the time.
Where the firm decides it can act with safeguards, record those too: who may see the file and who may not.
Keep checking after the matter opens
A check at intake compares the new matter with the firm as it was that day. The firm keeps changing: new clients arrive, new parties are added to old matters. A name that was clear in March may match a client taken on in June. Either re-run checks on open matters at intervals, or use a system that does so as records change.
How ChamberOne handles this
- A conflict check runs at intake across past clients and the parties on existing matters, and again every day as records change.
- Enquiries received through the public enquiry form show a name-based conflict warning before anyone opens them as a matter.
- The result is shown on the matter with the date it was checked.
- Matters can be restricted so that only named people can open them, and every read and change is written to the audit log.
What it does not do
- ChamberOne finds possible matches; it does not decide whether a conflict exists. That judgement stays with a lawyer.
- It can only search what has been entered. Parties kept in paper files or in someone's inbox are not checked until they are added.
This guide is general information about running a practice. It is not legal advice and does not describe what any statute, court rule or professional rule requires of you. Check the rules that apply to your practice.