ChamberOne

AI contract review: a first-pass checklist for lawyers

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Suppose an in-house lawyer receives a supplier agreement at four on a Thursday afternoon and the business wants a view by Friday. An AI tool can help her get her bearings in minutes. It can also lull her into thinking she has read the contract. This checklist separates the two: the questions worth putting to a tool on a first pass, and the parts of the document that only a lawyer's reading will cover.

Key points

  • Use AI to map a contract, then read the clauses that matter yourself.
  • Ask for clause numbers with every answer and open each clause before relying on it.
  • Tools are weakest on what is absent, so keep your own list of clauses you expect to find.
  • Follow cross-references and definitions by hand, because summaries often treat clauses in isolation.
  • Check where the document goes before pasting a client's contract into any tool.

What a first pass is for

A first pass answers three questions. What kind of document is this? Who owes what to whom, and when? Where is the risk likely to sit? It is a map of the contract, not a review of it.

Keep that distinction in view. An AI-generated summary is useful for orientation and for deciding where to spend your reading time. It is not a substitute for reading the clauses that matter, and it should never be the only thing a client's advice rests on.

Questions worth asking an AI first

Put plain, specific questions. The more the question points at the text, the easier it is to check the answer.

  • Who are the parties, in what capacity, and are their names consistent throughout?
  • What is the term, and how can it be renewed, extended or ended?
  • What are the payment terms, and what triggers payment?
  • List every obligation that falls on our client, with the clause number.
  • Which clauses limit or exclude liability, and what do they cover?
  • Which clauses deal with indemnities, termination, assignment, confidentiality, governing law and dispute resolution?
  • Which dates, notice periods and deadlines appear in the document?
  • Which defined terms are used but never defined?

Ask for clause numbers, then go and look

Insist that every point in the answer cites the clause or paragraph it came from. If the tool cannot point to text, you cannot check it, and you should treat the point as a suggestion only.

Then open the clause. It takes seconds, and it is the difference between knowing and hoping. A tool that summarises a termination clause as mutual may have missed the sentence that gives one party an extra right.

What tools tend to miss

Tools are better at describing what is on the page than at noticing what is not. These are the gaps to look for deliberately.

  • Missing clauses. A contract with no limitation of liability, no data protection terms or no dispute mechanism will not produce a flag, because there is nothing to flag. Keep your own list of clauses you expect to see and tick them off.
  • Cross-references. A clause that says it is subject to another clause, or a schedule that changes the effect of the main text, may be summarised in isolation. Follow the references yourself.
  • Definitions that change meaning. A defined term used in a clause can quietly widen or narrow it. Read the definition, not only the clause.
  • Order of precedence. Where the body, the schedules and the order form conflict, which prevails?
  • Tables, annexes and scanned pages. Layout and image quality can cause text to be skipped or misread.

Where you must read every word

Some provisions deserve full human reading whatever any tool says. Limitation and exclusion of liability, indemnities, termination rights, intellectual property ownership, payment and price adjustment, restrictive covenants, and anything the client has told you matters to them. Read these slowly, in context, with the definitions open beside them.

Also read the parts that are unusual. A tool trained on common contracts is least reliable on the odd drafting that a counterparty may have added on purpose.

Ask the tool first
  • Parties, term and payment terms, with clause numbers.
  • Every obligation that falls on your client.
  • Dates, notice periods and deadlines.
Read every word yourself
  • Limitation and exclusion of liability.
  • Indemnities and termination rights.
  • Intellectual property ownership and price adjustment.
  • Unusual drafting a counterparty may have added.
First-pass questions and the clauses you read yourself

Compare against your own position, and handle the document with care

A first pass is more useful when it is measured against something. If your firm or department has a standard position or a playbook, give the tool the relevant positions and ask where the draft departs from them. Treat each departure as a prompt for your attention, not a conclusion.

Without a playbook, ask the tool which clauses are one-sided and in whose favour, then decide for yourself whether that matters in this deal. Commercial context, such as the relative bargaining power of the parties and what the client is willing to give up, is not in the document.

Before you paste a client's contract into any AI tool, find out where the text goes, whether it is kept, and whether it may be used to train a model. Check your firm's policy and the guidance from your regulator or bar on confidentiality. The same contract may contain a confidentiality clause that restricts disclosure to third parties.

Record in the file that AI was used for the first pass and who reviewed the output. That makes supervision easier and answers a client who asks.

A short routine for the Thursday afternoon problem

Return to the in-house lawyer with the supplier agreement and a Friday deadline. A workable sequence takes about an hour of her time and uses the tool where it is strongest.

  1. 1

    Ask the tool for the document type, parties, term and payment terms, each with a clause number. Check those numbers against the text.

  2. 2

    Ask for every obligation on her own side and every right of the other side. Build her own table from the answer, correcting as she reads.

  3. 3

    Read the liability, indemnity, termination and intellectual property clauses in full, with definitions open.

  4. 4

    Tick off her list of expected clauses and note what is absent.

  5. 5

    Ask the tool for clauses that depart from the department's usual position, then decide which departures matter commercially.

  6. 6

    Write her advice in her own words, using the table as the working note.

Setting expectations with the business

Business colleagues sometimes assume that a tool makes legal review instant. It makes orientation quick. It does not make judgment quick. Say so at the start: a fast first pass is available, but the advice on risk still needs a lawyer's time.

It also helps to agree what the business wants back. A one-page list of issues, ranked by importance, with proposed changes, is usually more useful than a tracked-changes document with fifty comments. A tool can draft the list, but you decide the ranking.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

AI contract review: a first-pass checklist for lawyers