ChamberOne

AI for regulatory change monitoring: keeping clients updated

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

Every regulatory lawyer knows the feeling of hearing about a change from a client. A new consultation, an amended rule, a regulator's statement: it was published days ago and nobody at the firm saw it. Monitoring is dull work, and it is exactly the kind of dull work that software can help with. The danger is that a neat summary arrives in a client's inbox before anyone has read the thing it summarises.

Key points

  • Separate finding, sorting, understanding and communicating; AI helps most with the first two.
  • List official sources first and record who watches each one.
  • A lawyer reads the official text before any alert goes to a client.
  • Distinguish general alerts from advice and call clients on changes that matter to them.

What monitoring involves

There are four stages, and they are worth separating because AI helps with some and not others. First, finding: spotting that something new has been published. Second, sorting: deciding whether it matters to anyone you act for. Third, understanding: working out what it says and what it changes. Fourth, communicating: telling the right clients, in the right way, with the right level of confidence.

AI is strong at the first two and useful at the third. At the fourth it is a drafting aid, and the responsibility sits with the lawyer who sends the message.

Where AI helps
  • Finding: spotting that something new has been published
  • Sorting: deciding whether it matters to anyone you act for
  • Understanding: useful for working out what it says
Where the lawyer is responsible
  • Communicating: AI is only a drafting aid
  • The lawyer who sends the message owns it
  • Reading the official text before any client advice
Who does what in change monitoring

Choose your sources before your tool

A monitoring system is only as good as what it watches. List the official sources for each client sector: legislation sites, regulators' announcements and consultation pages, court and tribunal publications, official gazettes, and the relevant departments of government. Add secondary sources only as pointers.

Decide how each is checked. Some publish feeds or alerts. Others need a regular visit by a person or a tool. Record the list with the owner of each source, so that a gap is noticed when someone leaves.

Where AI helps in finding and sorting

  • Reading new publications and tagging them by subject, sector, jurisdiction and type, such as consultation, final rule or guidance.
  • Matching tags to client profiles, so that a change affecting data handling goes to clients in health or finance.
  • Producing a short, plain-language note of what the document appears to be about, for triage, with a link to the source.
  • Flagging deadlines that appear in the text, such as a consultation closing date, for a human to confirm.
  • Grouping related items, so that three publications on the same topic reach the reader together.

Everything in that list is a pointer, not a conclusion. The tool tells you where to look.

The step that must not be skipped

Before anything goes to a client as advice or as a firm view, a lawyer should read the official text. Not the summary, and not a law firm's blog post about it. The reason is simple: summaries leave things out, misstate effective dates and confuse proposals with enacted rules. A consultation paper is not a rule, and a model may describe it as though it were.

Confirm what stage the document has reached, whether it is in force, from when, to whom it applies and what transitional provisions say. Confirm the date as at which the text is current, and whether anything has amended it since. Where the answer depends on a regulator's guidance, check the guidance from your regulator or bar.

A weekly routine

  1. 1

    Monday: the tool produces a digest of new items from the monitored sources, tagged and ranked by relevance to your clients.

  2. 2

    A named lawyer scans the digest and marks each item: ignore, watch or act.

  3. 3

    For items marked 'act', the lawyer reads the official text and writes a short internal note: what changed, who is affected and what the deadline is.

  4. 4

    A second lawyer or partner reviews the note for anything that will go to clients.

  5. 5

    Client alerts go out only after that review, with a link to the official source.

  6. 6

    Items marked 'watch' are added to a tracker with a review date.

  1. 1The tool produces a tagged digest of new items
  2. 2A named lawyer marks each item: ignore, watch or act
  3. 3For 'act' items, the lawyer reads the official text and writes a note
  4. 4A second lawyer or partner reviews anything going to clients
  5. 5Alerts go out with a link to the official source
  6. Then back to step 1.
The weekly monitoring routine

Routing to clients

Keep a record of which clients care about which topics, and update it when instructions change. An alert about a rule that affects a client's industry is helpful. One that does not affect them is noise, and too much noise trains clients to ignore you.

Be clear about the service. Is the alert general information, or is it advice for that client? Say which. A general alert should say that it is not advice and invite the client to ask how it applies to them. Where a change affects a particular client in a major way, call them rather than relying on a bulk email.

Check your engagement terms and the guidance from your regulator or bar on what a monitoring service involves and what duties it creates. Offering a service implies a promise, and clients may assume you will catch everything.

Limits and risks

  • Coverage gaps. A tool that does not watch a source will never report it. Silence is not reassurance.
  • Misreading stage and scope. Proposals, drafts and final texts look alike to a model.
  • Jurisdiction mix-ups. A summary of a rule from one country can slip into a note about another.
  • False confidence. A confident summary sent without review can do more harm than no alert at all.
  • Confidentiality. If client profiles are fed to a tool to match topics, check where they go.

Treat AI monitoring as an assistant that lets you read more widely, with a human always reading what matters. Done that way, it helps a firm hear about changes earlier and tell clients with care.

A hypothetical example

Suppose a small regulatory team acts for a handful of payment companies. A consultation paper is published on a regulator's site. The monitoring tool tags it as relevant to three clients and flags a closing date. A lawyer opens the paper, finds that the proposals are some way from becoming rules, and writes a two-line internal note.

The alert to clients says that a consultation has opened, gives the closing date, links to the paper and offers a call. It does not say what the rules will be. When the final text appears months later, the same lawyer reads it again before writing anything further.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

AI for regulatory change monitoring in law firms