Lawyer wellbeing and AI: does it reduce pressure or raise it?
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
The promise is that AI takes the drudgery away and gives lawyers their evenings back. The risk is that it does the opposite. If a task that took three hours now takes one, the easy conclusion is that a lawyer can do three of them. Whether AI lightens the load or raises it depends less on the tool than on what the firm does with the time it frees.
Key points
- Time saved by AI is often absorbed by extra work unless the firm decides otherwise.
- Review is demanding in its own way. Rotate it, limit it and make it acceptable to reject a draft.
- Track hours, leave and error reports before and after introducing tools.
- Be honest with staff about how roles may change, and involve them in decisions.
How the time saved gets taken back
When a task speeds up, the extra capacity rarely stays empty. Partners may add work. Clients may expect faster turnaround, and ask for more in the same fee. Colleagues may assume that everything can be done quickly. The saving is real, yet it is absorbed. The lawyer is as busy as before, but now with more tasks in flight and less time to think about each.
None of this is malicious. It is the ordinary result of a system in which capacity is treated as a resource to be filled. If you want the benefit to reach people, you have to decide in advance that some of it will.
Review fatigue is a new kind of tiredness
Producing a draft is one kind of effort. Reading a draft for errors is another. Reviewing is hard work, because the text is plausible and the mistakes hide in plain sight. A lawyer who reviews AI output all day can end up more tired, not less, because the task has changed from creating to inspecting.
There is also a risk of complacency. After twenty accurate summaries, the twenty-first gets less attention. Errors tend to appear exactly when people have stopped expecting them.
- Limit how much AI-assisted review one person does in a sitting.
- Rotate review duties, so that the same person is not always the last line of defence.
- Build in different kinds of checks, such as tracing every figure to a source, so that attention is task-driven rather than skim-driven.
- Make it acceptable to say that a draft is not good enough and to reject it.
Protect some of the time saved
If a firm wants wellbeing to improve, it has to say how. A few approaches seem sensible, and each needs adapting to the firm.
- Agree that part of any time saved goes to learning, thinking or rest, and do not hand all of it to additional billable work.
- Review target hours and workload expectations when tools are introduced, not only when people complain.
- Check capacity before accepting work on the assumption that tools will make it quick.
- Give people permission to decline AI where they judge it unsuitable for a task.
- Agree part of the time saved goes to learning, thinking or rest
- Review workload expectations when tools are introduced
- Check capacity before accepting work
- Let people decline AI where it suits a task badly
- Hand all the saving to extra billable work
- Assume tools make every task quick
Watch for the signs
Wellbeing problems usually show up in small things before they show up in resignations. People stop taking leave. Messages arrive late at night. Errors increase, or the same person is catching everyone else's mistakes. Someone who used to speak up in meetings goes quiet.
Look at the data you already have: hours worked, leave taken, error reports and sickness absence. Compare the periods before and after tools were introduced. If hours have crept up while output has increased, the saving is going somewhere other than the people.
The anxiety about jobs
For some lawyers, the worry is not workload but the future. Juniors fear that routine tasks, the ones that taught them the work, will disappear. Mid-career lawyers wonder whether their experience will be valued. Support staff may fear for their roles.
Silence feeds this. Leaders do not need to make promises they cannot keep, but they can be honest about what they know, explain how the firm plans to use technology and involve people in the decisions. Fear is usually worse when people discover plans second-hand. Offer training, and talk about how roles may change rather than pretending they will not.
Small firms and sole practitioners
In a small firm there is no human resources department to notice a problem, and the person most at risk may be the owner. A sole practitioner who adopts tools in the hope of working less often ends up taking on more clients to fill the gap. If you work alone, decide in advance what the saving is for. Perhaps it is a fixed finishing time, a day without client work or a cap on the number of live matters. Write it down, and tell someone who will ask you about it. Without a rule, the saved hours drift back into work almost unnoticed.
What a good conversation looks like
Suppose a partner asks an associate how the new drafting tool is going. A useful answer is not it is great. It is something like this: it saves me an hour on first drafts but I spend forty minutes checking, and I am now being given more files. A partner who hears that can respond with something real, such as taking a file back or agreeing that the checking time is part of the job. Create the conditions in which that honest answer is possible.
A short check for partners each quarter
- Have target hours or work volumes changed since we introduced AI tools, and did we decide that deliberately?
- Who is doing most of the reviewing, and is that fair?
- Has anyone told us that the tools made their work harder, and what did we do about it?
- Are juniors still getting the experience they need to develop?
- 1Have target hours or volumes changed, and was that deliberate?
- 2Who is doing most of the reviewing, and is that fair?
- 3Has anyone said the tools made their work harder?
- 4Are juniors still getting the experience they need?
- 5Act on the answers, then repeat next quarter
- Then back to step 1.
What AI will not fix
Wellbeing in law has deep causes: long hours, high stakes, adversarial work, billing pressure and an uneven culture of support. A tool will not change those. It may make some tasks lighter and others heavier. Firms that want healthier working lives will get them by the choices they make about workload, supervision and respect, with technology as one input among many.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Training junior lawyers when AI does the first draft
If routine drafting shrinks, juniors need other ways to build judgment. Practical exercises that keep the learning in the work.
5 minute readThe skills lawyers need to work well with AI
Verification, precise instruction, source reading and client judgment: what to practise and how.
5 minute readLaw students and AI: learning to think before you prompt
AI can be a sparring partner for a law student, but only if you do the thinking first.
4 minute read