Mentoring juniors in judgment when AI writes faster
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
A first-year associate can now produce a clean-looking draft in the time it once took to find the right precedent. That sounds like progress, and in some ways it is. But the draft arrives without the struggle that used to teach people what a good one looks like. Senior lawyers have to put that learning back on purpose.
Key points
- Fluent AI drafts remove the slow work that used to teach judgment, so seniors must teach it on purpose.
- Have juniors write their own view first, list assumptions and check every legal proposition at source.
- Review by asking questions and explaining corrections, not by rewriting.
- Write down clear rules on tool use, and make honest use of tools normal.
What the old route taught without anyone noticing
Older lawyers learned judgment partly by accident. Hours spent reading cases taught them which authorities mattered. Redrafting a clause five times taught them how wording shifts risk. Being told by a partner that a letter was 'too keen' taught them tone. None of it was a syllabus. It came from doing slow work and being corrected.
When a tool shortcuts the slow work, the correction can disappear too. A junior hands in a tidy draft, the partner fixes three things, and neither says why. Nothing was learned, and the junior may now trust the next tidy draft a little too much.
The risk is not laziness, it is fluency
Most juniors are not trying to cut corners. The danger is that fluent text feels right. An AI draft is well organised, confident in tone and usually plausible. Spotting what is wrong with plausible text takes more skill than spotting what is wrong with a clumsy draft, and juniors have the least experience to do it with.
That makes review the key skill to teach. Not review as proofreading, but review as asking whether the answer is right, what it assumes and what it leaves out.
Habits that build discernment
These habits are simple. What makes them work is that a senior person insists on them until they stick.
- Write your own answer first. Before asking a tool, the junior jots down what they think the answer is and why, in a few lines. Then compare.
- State the assumptions. Every draft rests on facts, a jurisdiction and a client goal. The junior lists them.
- Open the source. Any proposition about the law gets checked against the primary source, not a summary of it.
- Say what is missing. What argument would the other side make? What facts would change this advice?
- Explain it aloud. The junior explains the answer to a colleague in two minutes, without looking at the screen.
- 1Write your own answer first
- 2Compare it with the tool's
- 3State the assumptions
- 4Open the source
- 5Say what is missing
- 6Explain it aloud
- Then back to step 1.
Review conversations that teach
The review meeting is where juniors learn or do not. A partner who rewrites the draft and sends it back has taught the junior very little. A partner who asks questions teaches a great deal.
Try asking: why did you choose this structure? Where did you check this? What would make you change your mind? What is the weakest point? How would you explain this to the client in plain words? These questions cost five minutes and show quickly whether the junior understands the answer or only possesses it.
When you correct something, say why. 'This clause is too wide for the client's position because they will be the one giving the indemnity' is a lesson. 'Narrow this' is only an instruction.
- Teaches the junior very little
- 'Narrow this' is only an instruction
- Teaches a great deal
- Ask where they checked and what would change their mind
- Explain the reason for each correction
Exercises that rebuild the slow skills
- The spot-the-error exercise: give a junior an AI draft with two or three planted mistakes and ask them to find them. Vary the type: a wrong date, a misread clause, an authority that does not say what is claimed.
- The blank-page task: now and then, ask for a short piece of work done without any tool, then compare it with a tool-assisted version.
- The reasoned redline: ask the junior to mark up a contract and write one sentence of reasoning for each change.
- The shadow hour: let a junior sit in on a client call or a negotiation, then discuss what the senior did and why.
Set clear rules on tool use
Juniors often do not know what is allowed, and fear that asking will make them look incompetent. Write down the firm's position: which tools are approved, what may and may not be pasted in, when a tool's output must be checked against a source, and when you must tell a supervisor or a client that a tool was used. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar on supervision and technology, since your duties as a supervisor are your own.
Make it plain that using a tool is fine and that hiding it is not. A junior who says 'I used the assistant for the first draft and checked the following three points' is doing exactly the right thing.
What seniors have to change too
Partners set the tone. If seniors reward speed above all, juniors will take the fastest route and skip checking. If seniors never admit that they use tools themselves, juniors will conceal their own use. If seniors do not read the work closely, nobody learns to produce work that deserves close reading.
Time is the real cost. Mentoring takes hours that cannot be billed. Firms that expect AI to produce free capacity should consider putting some of that capacity into teaching, because the quality of their lawyers in ten years depends on it.
Signs it is working
A junior who is developing judgment starts to raise issues unprompted. They flag an assumption before you ask. They tell you a source did not say what the tool claimed. They disagree with a draft and can say why. Those are the signs to look for, and they are worth far more than a quick turnaround.
Do not wait for the annual appraisal to talk about it. A short conversation every few weeks, asking what the junior found hard and what the tool got wrong, keeps the lesson alive and tells you where to focus next.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Training junior lawyers when AI does the first draft
If routine drafting shrinks, juniors need other ways to build judgment. Practical exercises that keep the learning in the work.
5 minute readThe skills lawyers need to work well with AI
Verification, precise instruction, source reading and client judgment: what to practise and how.
5 minute readLaw students and AI: learning to think before you prompt
AI can be a sparring partner for a law student, but only if you do the thinking first.
4 minute read