ChamberOne

Prompting skills for lawyers: practice exercises

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

Most disappointing AI output comes from a vague request. 'Summarise this contract' gets a summary that suits nobody in particular. The same document, with a clear instruction about who will read it and what they need, produces something useful. Prompting is not a trick. It is the old skill of briefing a junior well. These exercises give you practice at four tasks lawyers do every day.

Key points

  • A good instruction names the reader, the task, the material, the constraints and what to do when unsure.
  • Practise on summarising, comparing, drafting and critiquing with documents you know well.
  • Iterate, ask where the tool is unsure, and check anything you will rely on against the source.
  • Keep client details out of unapproved tools and keep a library of prompts that worked.

The ingredients of a good instruction

Think of briefing a capable trainee who knows nothing about your matter. Tell them these things.

  • Role and reader: who is the answer for, and what will they do with it?
  • Task: exactly what to produce, in one sentence.
  • Material: the text to work from, pasted in, with a note of anything missing.
  • Constraints: jurisdiction, length, format, tone, what to leave out.
  • Standard: say what to do when unsure. 'Say so and do not guess' is a useful line.

Exercise 1: summarise

Weak: 'Summarise this lease.' The tool decides what matters, and will probably choose generic points.

Stronger: 'You are helping a property solicitor advising a small business tenant. Summarise this lease for the client in under 300 words of plain English. Cover rent and review, term and break rights, repair obligations, assignment and subletting, and any unusual restrictions. For each point give the clause number. If something is not in the lease, say that it is absent, do not guess.'

Try it: take a short lease or contract you know well. Run both versions. Compare against your own reading. What did the weak version leave out? What did the strong one get wrong?

Weak: 'Summarise this lease.'
  • The tool decides what matters
  • It will probably choose generic points
Stronger instruction
  • Names the reader and purpose: a solicitor advising a small business tenant
  • Sets length and style: under 300 words of plain English
  • Lists what to cover, with clause numbers
  • Says to flag what is absent and not to guess
A weak and a stronger instruction

Exercise 2: compare

Weak: 'What are the differences between these two drafts?' You will get a mix of trivial wording changes and real ones, in no useful order.

Stronger: 'Compare version 1 and version 2 of this supply agreement. List only changes that affect rights, obligations, payment or risk, grouped by clause. For each, quote the old and new wording, and say in one sentence who benefits. Ignore formatting and typographical changes.'

Try it: take two drafts of a document with a planted change, such as a shortened notice period. Does the tool catch it? Does it quote the text correctly? Check each quotation.

Exercise 3: draft

Weak: 'Draft a confidentiality clause.' The result is generic and may suit a different legal system.

Stronger: 'Draft a mutual confidentiality clause for a services agreement between two companies governed by the law of [your jurisdiction]. The client is the service provider, so protect its right to keep copies for regulatory purposes. Use plain English, defined terms in capitals and numbered sub-clauses. List any assumptions you made at the end.'

Try it: compare the draft with your precedent bank. What does the tool include that you would not? What is missing? Treat the draft as raw material, never as ready to use.

Exercise 4: critique

Weak: 'Is this letter okay?' You will get praise and minor edits.

Stronger: 'Act as a sceptical senior partner reading this letter of advice before it goes out. Identify the three weakest points of reasoning, any statement a client could misunderstand and any place where I promise more than the facts support. Do not rewrite the letter. Explain each concern in two sentences.'

Try it: use a letter you wrote some time ago. Does the critique find real weaknesses? Does it invent problems? Use critique to stimulate your own thinking, not to replace it.

Iterate, then verify

The first answer is a starting point. Follow up.

  1. 1

    Ask the tool to point out where it is least sure.

  2. 2

    Ask for the source for each factual claim, then check the sources yourself.

  3. 3

    Narrow or widen: 'shorter', 'more cautious', 'for a non-lawyer'.

  4. 4

    Test with a counter-view: 'what would the other side say?'

  5. 5

    Compare against the original material line by line for anything you will rely on.

  6. 6

    Record in the file that a person checked it.

  1. 1Ask the tool where it is least sure
  2. 2Ask for sources and check them yourself
  3. 3Narrow or widen the answer
  4. 4Test it with a counter-view
  5. 5Compare with the original material before relying on it
  6. Then back to step 1.
Following up on a first answer

Habits that protect you

Remove or avoid client identifiers where you can, and use only tools your firm has approved. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar before putting confidential material into any tool. Never rely on a citation you have not found in a trusted source. Keep a personal library of instructions that worked, with notes on what to change for each matter.

Finally, practise in a safe place. A short weekly session with colleagues, comparing prompts and outputs on invented or public documents, will teach more than any course. The skill is the same as in any briefing: say what you want, say why and then check what you get.

Exercise 5: extract

Weak: 'Pull out the important dates.' The tool will decide what counts as important and may skip a date buried in a schedule.

Stronger: 'From the text below, list every date, deadline and time period, including notice periods and cure periods. Give the clause or paragraph number, quote the words, and say what each date triggers. If a date is stated only by reference to another document, say so. Do not infer dates that are not in the text.'

Try it: pick a contract with a date in a schedule and one set by reference to an event, such as thirty days after delivery. Does the tool find both? Does it calculate anything for you? If so, check the arithmetic yourself.

Running a practice session with colleagues

Pick one exercise, use a public or invented document and give everyone ten minutes to write their own instruction. Put the instructions side by side without the outputs first. Which is clearest? Then compare the outputs. Where they differ, trace it back to a word in the instruction. Rotate who leads each month, and keep the best instructions in a shared folder with a note of what each is for and what to check afterwards. Ten minutes of this teaches more about instruction than an hour of reading advice.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Prompting skills for lawyers: practice exercises