ChamberOne

Telling clients you use AI: when and how to disclose

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

Sooner or later a client will ask, 'Do you use AI on my file?' The worst answer is a pause. The second worst is a vague one. Firms that have thought it through can reply in two sentences and move on. Firms that have not end up improvising, and clients notice. This article is for partners and client relationship leads. It offers a way to decide what to say, where to say it and when to go further and ask for consent. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar for what applies to you.

Key points

  • Decide which uses are worth mentioning, based on whether client information leaves the firm and whether the tool shapes substance.
  • Put a short, plain paragraph in the engagement letter and avoid promises such as 'we never use AI'.
  • Prepare spoken answers on use, review, data and opt-out, because the conversation matters more than the clause.
  • Ask for specific consent for sensitive matters, restricted data and tools with weak terms, and honour a refusal.

Why disclose at all

Clients trust you with sensitive information and pay for your judgement. If a tool plays a real part in the work, many clients will want to know, for the same reasons they want to know who is on the team and where documents are stored.

There is also a plain business reason. A client who learns about AI use later, from someone else, may feel misled even if the use was careful. A client who heard it early, in plain words, usually treats it as one more detail of how the firm works.

Decide what counts as use worth mentioning

Not every use needs a sentence. Spell checking and a search tool inside your email are different from sending a client's contract to an AI provider for analysis. A helpful dividing line is whether client information leaves the firm's own systems, and whether the tool shapes the substance of advice or documents.

Write the line down. It will be the same line you use in your AI policy, and your staff should be able to apply it without asking a partner every time.

A short paragraph for the engagement letter

Keep it plain. It should say that the firm may use AI-based tools to help with tasks such as summarising or drafting, that a lawyer reviews all output and remains responsible for the advice, that client information is handled under the firm's confidentiality duties and the firm's policy, and that the client can ask questions or ask the firm not to use such tools on their matter.

Avoid long technical language and avoid promises you cannot keep. 'We never use AI' becomes false the first time a tool is built into your software. 'AI makes our work cheaper' is a claim about fees that needs support and agreement.

Do
  • Keep it plain
  • Say a lawyer reviews all output and remains responsible
  • Say client information is handled under confidentiality duties
  • Say the client can ask questions or ask you not to use such tools
Don't
  • Use long technical language
  • Promise 'We never use AI'
  • Claim 'AI makes our work cheaper' without support and agreement
Wording about AI in an engagement letter

Conversations matter more than clauses

Most clients will not read a paragraph in the letter closely. The real disclosure happens when a partner speaks to them. Prepare a few lines: what the tools do, what the lawyer does, where the data goes, and what the client can choose. Practise saying it without jargon.

  • What do you use it for? 'To speed up first drafts and to summarise long documents.'
  • Who checks it? 'A lawyer reads and is responsible for everything we send you.'
  • Where does my information go? Answer from your vendor's terms, not from memory.
  • Can I opt out? Say yes, if that is your policy, and explain what it means for time and cost.

When specific consent is wise

General wording in a letter may be enough for routine use. Some situations call for a specific conversation and a written yes. These include matters involving unusually sensitive material, such as health, immigration status or national security. They include cases where a client has a contractual or regulatory restriction on where its data may be processed. They include any case where information would be sent to a tool whose terms allow the provider to keep or reuse it.

Corporate clients may have their own rules, and many send outside counsel guidelines that address AI. Read those before you start and respond to them in writing.

General wording may do
  • Routine use of AI tools
  • Covered by a plain paragraph in the engagement letter
Ask for a specific yes
  • Unusually sensitive material such as health, immigration status or national security
  • A client restriction on where data may be processed
  • A tool whose terms let the provider keep or reuse inputs
General wording or a specific written yes

When a client says no

Honour it, and make sure everyone on the matter knows. Mark the file. Check that tools built into your software are off for that matter or that you have another way of ensuring they are not used. If the tools you use cannot be turned off for one matter, tell the client honestly and let them decide whether to proceed.

Do not treat a refusal as a negotiation about price. Some clients will accept a different arrangement, and that is their choice to make.

Handling the questions clients ask next

Once you have told a client about AI, expect follow-ups. Can you use it for my letters? Does it make this cheaper? What if I do not like the answer? Give yourself ready replies. For the first, say which tasks use it and which never do. For the second, say that fees follow the work actually done and the agreement in the letter, and avoid implying a discount you have not agreed.

For the third, say that the lawyer decides and stands behind the advice. A client who hears that the lawyer's judgement is untouched by the tool tends to relax. A client who hears vague reassurance tends to ask again, more sharply.

Keep a short log of client questions about AI across the firm. After a few months it will show you what your letter fails to explain and which sentence to change.

What to do if something goes wrong

If a mistake involving AI affects a client, such as confidential text sent to the wrong tool or an error that reaches a deliverable, tell the client promptly and plainly, and explain what you have done. Your regulator's guidance may say more about notifying clients and others. A firm that discloses early keeps more trust than one that is found out.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Telling clients you use AI: when and how to disclose