ChamberOne

Training contracts, pupillage and articles in the AI era

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

For generations, trainees learned the law by doing the routine work: reading the bundle, drafting the first letter, preparing the chronology, summarising the case. That work was often dull, and it was also how they learned what mattered. When a tool can produce a first version in seconds, the question for training principals is what the trainee should do instead. For trainees, the question is how to show that they are worth training. This article is general, and the form of training differs between places, so check what your regulator or professional body expects of the training period.

Key points

  • Routine tasks taught judgment as well as producing work. Protect the learning when tools take over the first draft.
  • Have trainees do some tasks unaided, then compare with tool output, and teach checking as a skill.
  • Trainees can show judgment by being open about tool use, checking everything and asking why.
  • Check what your regulator or professional body expects of the training period, and keep a record of tasks done.

What the routine work was teaching

Reading a bundle teaches how a case is built, which documents matter and how people write when they do not expect to be read by a court. Drafting a letter teaches precision and tone. Preparing a chronology teaches the facts as nothing else does. None of it was only about the product. It was about forming a lawyer's eye.

If the tool does these tasks and the trainee merely reads the result, the trainee may know what a good summary looks like without ever having built one. The result can be a lawyer who is good at approving and poor at judging.

What supervisors can do

The answer is not to ban tools. It is to design the training so that the learning still happens. A few practical measures help.

  • Have trainees do some tasks without AI first, such as reading a document and summarising it, then compare their work with a tool's output and discuss the differences.
  • Ask trainees to explain the reasoning behind a draft, not only deliver it.
  • Give trainees checking work, and teach how to check: tracing facts, opening authorities, finding what is missing.
  • Include time on tasks that tools do badly: client conversations, negotiation, advocacy, spotting a conflict, reading a person.
  • Rotate trainees through different kinds of work, so that they see the whole shape of a matter.
  • Set expectations in writing: which tools may be used, for what, and with what supervision.

A scenario: the chronology

Suppose a training principal in a small litigation firm gives a trainee a new set of documents. In week one the trainee builds the chronology by hand. The principal reads it with them and asks why some entries are in and others out. In week two, on a new matter, the trainee uses the firm's approved tool to produce a first chronology and checks every entry against the documents, recording the errors found. The principal asks what the tool missed and why. Over a few months the trainee learns both the craft and how to supervise a machine.

Week one: by hand
  • The trainee builds the chronology by hand
  • The principal asks why some entries are in and others out
Week two: with the tool
  • The trainee uses the approved tool for a first chronology
  • Every entry is checked and the errors recorded
  • The principal asks what the tool missed and why
Learning the chronology in two stages

Keep the feedback loop

Training depends on feedback. A trainee who sends a draft produced by a tool, and receives corrections, is learning from the tool's mistakes rather than their own. Ask what part was theirs. Make sure the comments you give address the trainee's reasoning, such as why an authority was chosen or why the structure helps the reader. Where the draft was mostly generated, say so, and agree how to learn from it.

What trainees can do to show judgment

If you are a trainee, the tool can make you look productive without making you better. Employers and principals want to see something else: that you understand the work.

  • Be open about what you used and what you checked. Honesty builds trust faster than polish.
  • Check everything and keep a note of the errors you caught. It shows care and helps you learn.
  • Ask why. If a partner changes a draft, find out the reason.
  • Do some tasks the slow way when you are learning something new.
  • Volunteer for client contact, hearings and meetings, where the human part of the job is learned.
  • Learn the underlying law properly. You cannot spot a tool's mistake in an area you do not understand.
Do
  • Be open about what you used and what you checked
  • Check everything and keep a note of errors caught
  • Ask why when a partner changes a draft
  • Learn the underlying law properly
Don't
  • Let the tool make you look productive without making you better
  • Trust output in an area of law you do not understand
How trainees show judgment

Competence, assessment and records

Training periods usually involve some form of recording and assessment: skills to be developed, experience to be gained and sign-off by a principal. Check what your regulator or professional body expects, and whether it has said anything about technology. Principals should be able to say, truthfully, that a trainee has done and understood the core tasks, not just supervised a tool doing them. Keep a simple log of the tasks a trainee has done unaided, the tasks done with tools, and what was learned.

Confidentiality and tool use by trainees

Trainees are often keen users of new tools, and sometimes use personal accounts without thinking about client data. Make the rules clear on day one: approved tools only, no client material in free consumer products and a named person to ask. A trainee who puts a client's document into the wrong tool has made a serious mistake, and it is the firm's job to prevent it by being explicit.

Wellbeing and fairness in training

Trainees are often anxious about their futures, and AI adds to the worry. Principals can help by being honest about how roles are changing and by showing where trainees add value. Fairness matters, too. If some trainees get more hands-on work and others are given only checking tasks, the difference may affect how well they develop. Review the distribution of work, and make adjustments.

Questions for the interview and the review

  • Principals: how does a trainee at this firm learn to draft and to check, and what part of the work is done without tools?
  • Trainees: which tasks will I do unaided in my first six months?
  • Both: who reviews work, and how do we handle a mistake involving a tool?

What stays the same

Clients still want a lawyer who understands their problem, tells them the truth and takes responsibility. Courts still rely on advocates who know the material. Those qualities are developed by practice, supervision and reflection, and a good traineeship has always provided them. The tools change the tasks, but the aim remains the same: to produce a competent, trustworthy lawyer.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Training contracts, pupillage and articles in the AI era