ChamberOne

Triaging new client enquiries with AI while keeping conflict checks first

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

Monday morning. Eighteen enquiries arrived over the weekend. Some are urgent, some are in areas the firm does not cover, and one is from a name that sounds familiar. Someone on the practice management team has to read them all, work out who should see each one and answer before the weekend's worry turns into a visit to a competitor. This is a sorting job, and AI is good at sorting. It is a poor judge of whether to take a client. This article describes a process that uses the first and keeps the second with a person.

Key points

  • Run the conflict check before any substantive help, across past and present clients and parties.
  • Use AI to sort by area, urgency and names, and to suggest a lawyer.
  • Never let a tool accept, reject or lower the urgency of an enquiry without a person looking.
  • Tell enquirers how their message is handled and review the tool's sorting every month.

What triage means

Triage is the work between an enquiry arriving and a lawyer deciding whether to act. It has four jobs: understand what the person needs, judge how urgent it is, check whether the firm can act, and send it to the right person.

A tool can help with the first two and part of the third. Only the firm can do the last, and only a lawyer can decide to accept the instructions.

Conflict check first, always

Put the conflict check at the start. If the enquiry names a party your firm already acts against, or a former client with a related matter, the worst outcome is to discuss the case in detail before you find out.

Run names through your records before anyone gives substantive help. Check the enquirer, the other side and anyone else named. A check should look across past and present clients, parties and related companies. Remember that names are messy: spellings vary, companies change names, and people use nicknames. Treat a match as a warning to investigate and a non-match as a reason for further care.

What AI can sort

  • Area of law: property, employment, family, commercial, criminal and so on, with a note when the enquiry fits more than one.
  • Urgency: flag mentions of court dates, deadlines, arrests, evictions or limitation periods, so a person reads those first.
  • Language and location: which jurisdiction the matter appears to involve, and whether it falls outside your practice.
  • Names mentioned, for the conflict check.
  • A one-line summary of what the person is asking for.
  • A suggested lawyer or team, based on the area and your own rules.

What it should not decide

Do not let a tool accept or reject an enquiry. Do not let it send a reply that gives an opinion on the person's problem. Do not let it assign a priority that lowers a case because it sounds unimportant. A calm email may hide a deadline tomorrow.

Set a rule that the tool can raise urgency but never lower it without a person looking. Also decide what happens to enquiries the tool cannot classify. They should go to a person, not to a pile.

Do
  • Sort by area of law and urgency
  • Pull out the names for the conflict check
  • Write a one-line summary
  • Suggest a lawyer or team
Don't
  • Accept or reject an enquiry
  • Send a reply that gives an opinion
  • Lower urgency without a person looking
  • Leave unclassified enquiries in a pile
Sorting new enquiries

A routine that works

Suppose a four-lawyer firm sets this up. Enquiries come in through a form. A person reviews the list each morning and each afternoon. The tool offers a suggested area, urgency and lawyer for each. The practice manager checks any enquiry marked urgent first. A conflict check runs on every name before any lawyer calls back. The lawyer reads the enquiry, decides whether to accept, and, if so, opens the matter and sends the engagement letter. If not, a polite letter explains and suggests where else to look.

Everything is recorded. The reason for declining is noted, because it may matter if the person returns or complains.

Be honest with enquirers

Tell people what happens to their message. If a tool reads it first, say so in a sentence on the form. Ask them not to include more detail than needed. Remind them that submitting an enquiry does not make the firm their lawyer, and that deadlines still run while they wait. For anyone who may face an urgent deadline, include a phone number and say what to do if it cannot wait.

Handling the awkward enquiries

Some enquiries do not fit. A person writes a long account of several problems at once. A message is in a language nobody at the firm reads. A caller is distressed, or describes something that sounds like a risk to safety. A tool may classify these badly and a person should read them first.

Decide in advance what the rules are. Messages with words suggesting an emergency go to the duty lawyer. Messages from existing clients go to the responsible lawyer, not through general intake. Messages that look like spam or a sales pitch are filtered by a person, not deleted by a tool, since a genuine enquiry can look odd.

For enquiries outside your practice, a polite and quick reply that points to a bar association's referral service or another source of help is a service to the person, and it costs little. Avoid naming a specific rival firm unless you have a referral arrangement. Keep a template for this and have a person check each use.

Review how well the sorting works

Every month, sample twenty or so enquiries and compare the tool's classification with what a person would have done. Look at errors in urgency first, since those hurt most. Note which enquiry types it gets wrong, such as mixed matters or enquiries in a second language, and adjust the rules or add a manual step for those.

  1. 1Sample about twenty enquiries
  2. 2Compare with what a person would have done
  3. 3Look at urgency errors first
  4. 4Adjust the rules or add a manual step
  5. Then back to step 1.
The monthly sorting review

Enquiries and conflict warnings in ChamberOne

  • Each firm has a public enquiry form with its own link.
  • Enquiries arrive in an inbox with a name-based conflict warning.
  • At intake, the check looks across past clients and parties and shows what it found.
  • Add notes, then convert an enquiry to a client, a lead or a matter.

What it does not do

  • A conflict check result is a warning based on names. The decision to act stays with the lawyer.
  • Nothing from the enquiry form becomes a client until someone at the firm converts it.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Triaging client enquiries with AI and conflict checks