ChamberOne

AI task suggestions and matter phases: standardising how work starts

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Ask three lawyers in the same firm to open a residential sale and you may get three different first weeks. One orders searches on day one. Another waits for the contract. A third forgets to check the identity documents until completion looms. Variation is not always a problem, but unplanned variation is. Matter-type templates and suggested tasks give a firm a starting point everyone shares. This article explains how to set one up and how to keep it honest.

Key points

  • Consistent starting points reduce avoidable early mistakes and make files easier to hand over.
  • Structure templates in three layers: matter type, phases and tasks.
  • Treat AI task suggestions as a junior's list of ideas, to be accepted or rejected by a person.
  • Ask four questions of every suggestion: relevance, local fit, timing and responsibility, and what is missing.
  • Give each matter type an owner and update it after closed matters.

Why starting points matter

The first few days of a matter are when avoidable mistakes enter: a conflict check skipped, an engagement letter not sent, a deadline not diarised. A consistent opening sequence reduces those risks and makes the file easier for a colleague to pick up.

It also saves effort. Nobody should have to remember, from scratch, every step of an uncomplicated file they have opened fifty times.

Suppose a five-lawyer firm does a steady flow of residential sales, wills and small employment matters. Each lawyer has a private mental checklist. When one is on holiday, the covering lawyer discovers that the checklist never existed on paper: nobody knows whether the identity documents were verified or whether the searches have been ordered. A shared template turns private habits into a shared record.

Three layers: type, phase, task

A simple structure has three layers. The matter type says what kind of work this is, such as a residential sale, an employment claim or a company incorporation. Each type has phases, the stages the work normally passes through. Each phase has tasks, the steps that should happen in it.

Keep phase names plain and few. Four to six phases are usually enough for a matter type. More than that, and people stop updating the current phase, which makes reports on where files stand unreliable.

Write these down for your five most common matter types first. Leave the rare ones for later.

Involve the people who do the work, not only the partners. A paralegal who has opened two hundred files knows which step everyone forgets and which one is always done in the wrong order. Their knowledge is the raw material of a good template.

What belongs in a template

  • The phases, in the order they usually occur.
  • Default tasks for each phase, with a role responsible and a typical timing.
  • The fields the firm always wants captured, such as key dates, the other side's representative or the property address.
  • The engagement letter template that fits this type of work.
  • Notes on what is out of scope, so the first conversation with the client covers it.

Where AI suggestions fit in

A template gives the standard tasks. Suggestions can add to it. When a lawyer opens a matter with unusual features, an AI tool can propose tasks based on what it knows about the matter, such as an extra step for a company party or a foreign element. These are prompts to think, not instructions.

Treat a suggestion as a junior colleague's list of ideas. Some will be right, some unnecessary and some wrong for the jurisdiction or the client. A person decides which to adopt.

Suppose a lawyer opens a company sale in which one of the shareholders lives abroad and another is a trust. The template gives the usual tasks. A suggestion might add checking authority to sign for the trust and considering the effect of the overseas shareholder on the paperwork. The lawyer reads both, keeps the first, and decides that the second needs a partner's input before anything goes on the list.

How to review a suggestion

Build a habit of asking four questions of each suggested task before accepting it.

  1. 1

    Is this relevant to this matter and this client?

  2. 2

    Does it fit the law and procedure where we practise?

  3. 3

    Is the timing realistic, and who is responsible?

  4. 4

    Is anything obviously missing that the suggestion does not mention?

Keeping templates alive

A template that nobody updates becomes a source of errors. Give each matter type an owner, a partner or senior associate who reviews it at fixed intervals and whenever the law or procedure changes. After each closed matter, ask whether a step was missing or unnecessary, and feed that back.

If suggestions are repeatedly accepted for a certain type of matter, that is a signal to add them to the template. If they are repeatedly rejected, that is a signal the tool is not helping there.

Keep an eye on the tasks that are never completed. A step that is routinely deleted or ignored may be unnecessary, or it may be a step that people avoid because it is hard. Find out which before you remove it.

  1. 1Owner reviews the template at fixed intervals
  2. 2Review again when law or procedure changes
  3. 3Note what each closed matter showed
  4. 4Add suggestions that keep being accepted
  5. 5Check tasks that are never completed
  6. Then back to step 1.
Keeping a matter template up to date

Avoiding tick-box work

Standard task lists have a downside. People can tick boxes without thinking, and an unusual matter can be squeezed into a template that does not fit. Make clear that the template is a floor, not a ceiling, and that a lawyer remains responsible for deciding what a particular matter needs.

Say this out loud when you introduce a template, and say it again when a mistake happens. People follow the culture they see, and a firm that praises a lawyer for spotting what the template missed will get more of that.

Review a few completed files each quarter. Check whether the tasks were done for a reason, or just because they were there.

Make the template visible to clients where it helps. A short description of the phases of a typical matter, and what the client needs to do in each, sets expectations and cuts down the number of calls asking what happens next. It also gives the client a reason to supply documents on time.

How ChamberOne handles this

  • Phases, default tasks, custom fields and the engagement letter template come from the matter type.
  • You can ask for suggested tasks on a matter.
  • Each AI output stays a draft until someone accepts it.
  • Every AI call is recorded in the audit log with the model and token counts.

What it does not do

  • Suggested tasks are drafts produced by an AI model. They can be wrong or incomplete, and a lawyer decides what to accept.
  • ChamberOne does not give legal advice and does not decide what a matter needs.
  • AI features can be switched off for the firm. With them off, nothing is sent to an AI provider.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

AI task suggestions and matter phases for law firms