ChamberOne

Meeting and attendance notes with AI: consent, accuracy and storage

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

After a long client meeting, writing the attendance note is the job nobody wants. A tool that records the conversation and produces a transcript and summary looks like the answer. It can be, but the moment you press record you have created a new record about your client, with new rules about consent, accuracy and where it is kept.

Key points

  • Treat the recording, the transcript and the summary as three different records with different risks.
  • Check the recording and consent rules where you practise, and ask all participants before recording.
  • Do not record sensitive conversations by default, and offer an alternative.
  • Read the summary against the transcript and correct it before filing, paying attention to names, numbers and negatives.
  • Store transcripts with the matter and decide how long recordings are kept.

What these tools do, and what they produce

Most tools capture audio from a meeting, in person or online, turn it into a written transcript, and then produce a summary and a list of actions. Some identify speakers. Some work live, and some after the meeting.

There are three distinct products here: the recording, the transcript and the summary. Each has different risks. The recording is the most complete and the most sensitive. The transcript is searchable and verbatim but contains errors. The summary is readable but reflects choices made by the tool about what mattered.

Consent and recording rules

The rules on recording conversations vary between countries, between states within a country, and between types of meeting. In some places the consent of all participants is needed. In others, one party's consent is enough. Professional rules and client expectations add another layer. Do not assume that what is acceptable in one market applies in another. Check the law and the guidance from your regulator or bar.

A practice that works everywhere is to ask. Tell every participant before the meeting that you plan to use a recording tool, explain what happens to the recording, and take no offence if someone says no. Record that consent, in the file or in the transcript itself. For online meetings, say so at the start and make sure that the tool's notice is visible.

Do
  • Tell every participant before the meeting
  • Explain what happens to the recording
  • Record the consent on the file or in the transcript
  • For online meetings, say so at the start
Don't
  • Assume one market's rules apply in another
  • Take offence if someone says no
Recording meetings with an AI tool

Special care for sensitive conversations

Some meetings should not be recorded: a vulnerable client discussing safety, an employee describing a harassment complaint, a client making a candid statement about a risk they have taken. A recording can chill a conversation, and a transcript can be disclosed in ways that you did not intend.

Offer an alternative. A client who is uncomfortable should be able to say so without cost, and you should be ready to take handwritten notes. In a meeting with other parties present, such as a mediation or a negotiation, check the agreed terms before recording anything.

Accuracy: what the tool gets wrong

Transcripts are good on clear speech in quiet rooms and bad on accents, crosstalk, jargon and names. The usual faults are easy to describe and easy to miss when reading quickly.

  • Names of people, companies and places misspelled or swapped.
  • Numbers and dates misheard, or silently corrected to something plausible.
  • Negatives dropped, so that 'we did not agree' becomes 'we agreed'.
  • Speakers wrongly attributed, so that a client's statement is credited to the other side.
  • Summaries that smooth over doubt, so that a tentative remark becomes an instruction.

Review before filing

An attendance note is a professional record. It may be relied on in a fee dispute, a negligence claim or a hearing about what was said. The lawyer who attended should read the summary against their own memory and correct it before it is filed. For anything important, check the transcript itself, especially the passages dealing with instructions, advice, deadlines and figures.

Decide whether the note on the file is the summary, the transcript or a version edited by the lawyer, and make clear which. Mark machine-generated text as such until reviewed. Add anything the tool could not capture, such as documents shown or a client's visible distress.

Treat transcripts as client records

A transcript is as confidential as the meeting. It should be stored with the matter, under the same access rules, and kept for as long as the file. It may be subject to a client's request for their file or to disclosure in proceedings, so think about the content before you create it.

Decide how long recordings are kept. Many firms keep the summary and the transcript and delete the audio once the note is approved, but whether that is appropriate depends on the matter and the rules that apply to you. Write the decision down in a policy. Check where the vendor stores recordings and transcripts, who can access them and whether they are used to improve the tool.

Trying it out safely

Start with a low-stakes use: an internal team meeting, or a call with a colleague at another firm who has agreed to be recorded. Compare the tool's summary with what you remember, and note what it missed. A few such tests will teach you the tool's habits more safely than a first trial on a client's most important meeting.

Then agree rules with the whole team. Which tool is approved? Who may record? Where does the output go? Who deletes what, and when? A one-page policy is enough. Without one, individuals will make their own choices, and those will differ.

Consider also what a transcript reveals about you. A candid aside, a joke about the other side or a half-formed view can look different in writing. Remember that anything said in a recorded meeting may be read later by someone who was not there, and speak accordingly.

A short procedure for fee earners

Before the meeting, check that the tool is approved, that consent has been given and that the setting is suitable. During the meeting, say the date and the participants at the start, and spell any unusual names. After the meeting, read the summary against the transcript within a day, correct it, file the approved version with the matter and deal with the audio under the firm's policy. If the tool fails, write your own note straight away.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

AI meeting and attendance notes for lawyers | ChamberOne