Workflow automation for law firms: where a practice manager should start
By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read
Practice managers are often told that automation will transform the firm. They are rarely told where to begin. The honest answer is somewhere dull. The best candidates are the steps that happen often, follow the same pattern and do little harm if they go slightly wrong. This article gives a way to find them: map what people actually do, score each step and start at the top of a short list.
Key points
- Find automation candidates by watching what people actually do, not by shopping for software.
- Map each repetitive process as a short list of steps with who, how long and how often.
- Score volume, repetition and time cost, then subtract risk if wrong.
- Start with dull, frequent, low-risk steps and leave client-facing sending and legal judgment alone.
- Measure before and after, and involve the people whose work will change.
Begin by watching, not buying
Before looking at any software, spend a week finding out what people really do. Sit with a secretary, a paralegal and a fee earner for an hour each. Ask them to talk you through their last working day, and note every step that involves copying, retyping, chasing or checking the same thing twice.
Ask one question repeatedly: what do you do that you wish you did not have to? The answers are your raw material.
Suppose a six-lawyer firm hears the same answer from three different people: new matters take far too long to open. One person retypes client details into four places. Another chases identity documents by email. A third forgets the first diary entry. The pattern shows exactly where to start, and nobody had to buy anything to find it.
Map the steps
Write each repetitive process as a short list of steps. Opening a new matter, for example, might be: receive instruction, run a conflict check, collect identity documents, open the file, send the engagement letter, diarise the first review. Next to each step, note who does it, how long it takes and how often it happens.
A rough map on a whiteboard is enough. Precision is less important than finding the steps people complain about.
Photograph the whiteboard and keep it. When you come back after three months, you will want to see what the process looked like before. It also helps new colleagues understand why a step exists, which prevents it being quietly dropped or duplicated later.
A simple scoring grid
Score each step from one to five on four questions. Then add them up, treating risk as a deduction.
- Volume: how often does this happen? Five is daily, one is a few times a year.
- Repetition: is it the same every time? Five means identical, one means every case differs.
- Time cost: how much staff time does it use in a month? Five is a lot.
- Risk if wrong: what happens if the automated step makes a mistake? Five means serious harm, such as a missed court date or a breach of confidence.
How to read the scores
Add volume, repetition and time cost, then subtract the risk score. The steps with the highest results are your candidates: frequent, repetitive, time-consuming and harmless if they go wrong.
Steps with high risk are not off limits. They need a human check built in. A step that scores high on everything including risk might be automated with a review stage: the system prepares, a person approves.
Take the opening of a new matter as an example. Volume is high, repetition is high, time cost is moderate, and risk is moderate because a missed conflict check matters. The sensible design has the system create the file and the standard tasks, and then stops for a lawyer to confirm the conflict result before work begins.
Frequent, repetitive, time-consuming and harmless if they go wrong.
The system prepares and a person approves.
Low scores overall, so not the first candidates.
Little to gain and serious harm if wrong.
What usually ranks well
- Filling the same details into several documents from one record.
- Sending routine reminders for appointments, tasks and overdue invoices.
- Creating standard task lists when a matter of a known type opens.
- Collecting documents and information from clients with a form.
- Producing regular internal reports that someone builds by hand each month.
What to leave alone, at least at first
- Anything that sends communications to clients without review.
- Steps that involve a judgment about law, such as deciding whether a deadline applies.
- Rare, complicated processes that few people understand.
- Anything touching client money, until you have specialist advice on the rules that apply.
- Steps that are broken today. Automating a bad process makes the mess faster.
- Filling the same details into several documents.
- Sending routine reminders.
- Creating standard task lists for known matter types.
- Collecting client documents with a form.
- Client communications sent without review.
- Steps involving a judgment about law.
- Rare, complicated processes.
- Anything touching client money.
- Steps that are broken today.
Start small and measure
Pick the top one or two steps. Before changing anything, record how long they take now. Introduce the automation for one team, run it alongside the old method for a short period, and compare. Ask the people affected whether it really saves them time and whether it introduced new problems.
A modest win in the first month does more for the firm's appetite for change than a large project that is still in planning a year later.
Share the result with everyone, including the numbers. Saying that a step used to take twenty minutes and now takes five, with the person who used to do it nodding in the room, is more persuasive than any presentation about transformation.
Keep people involved
Staff who fear that automation threatens their jobs will not help you find the dull steps. Say plainly that the aim is to remove drudgery and free time for work that needs judgment and contact with clients, and show that by acting on what they tell you. Review the process after three months, since steps change and automations that were right at the start may need adjusting.
Where a step is removed, say what the person who did it will do instead. Time that is saved and not redirected simply disappears, and the next suggestion from the same team will be met with silence.
Write down who owns each automation and what to do when it breaks. An automated step that fails silently is worse than a manual one, because nobody notices. A weekly glance at whether the reminders, forms and task lists are still firing is enough.
This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.
Read next
Onboarding a new client matter: an AI-assisted step-by-step checklist
Walk through every step of opening a new matter — from conflict check to task assignment — showing where AI saves time and where only a lawyer can decide.
6 minute readUsing AI matter briefs to pick up an unfamiliar file quickly
How a generated brief speeds up handovers and cover, and how to check it against the file before acting.
5 minute readAI task suggestions and matter phases: standardising how work starts
How matter-type templates and suggested tasks help new files start consistently, and why each suggestion needs review.
5 minute read