ChamberOne

Fixed-fee pricing with AI-assisted scoping

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Partners often want to move to fixed fees and hesitate because they are afraid of getting the number wrong. The fear is reasonable. A fixed fee moves the risk of overrun from the client to the firm. The way to reduce that risk is not to guess better. It is to scope better, using what the firm already knows about similar work. This article describes a method, and shows where AI summaries can speed up the groundwork without setting the price for you.

Key points

  • Base a fixed fee on what similar matters took, looking at the spread and the reasons for outliers.
  • AI summaries can speed up reviewing past files, but check pricing drivers against the file itself.
  • Describe scope as lists of what is included and excluded, including rounds of comments and meetings.
  • Name the events that change the fee, and say what happens when they occur.
  • Record time on fixed-fee matters and compare after closing so the next fee rests on data.

Start from what similar matters really took

The most reliable basis for a fixed fee is history. Pick the type of matter you want to price and pull the last twenty or so that closed. For each, note the hours recorded, who did them, the stages the matter went through and anything unusual that added effort.

Look at the spread, not just the average. If most matters cluster in a narrow band and a few run far over, find out why. The reasons usually become your exclusions.

Suppose a four-lawyer firm drafts shareholders' agreements for small companies. Looking back at the files, the partners find that most took a similar number of hours, and the long ones nearly always involved a founder who joined or left during negotiation. That observation becomes a clear exclusion: a change in the parties after the first draft is charged separately.

Be wary of small samples. Five matters tell you little, and one unusual file can distort an average. If you have few comparable files, price cautiously, keep the review point and use the first ten matters to learn.

Where AI summaries help

Reading twenty old files to see what happened is slow. A summary of each matter, covering the parties, the key events, the documents and the turning points, can speed that up. It lets a partner see quickly which files were straightforward and which hit trouble, and why.

Treat the summaries as an index, not as evidence. Check the facts that drive your pricing, such as the number of rounds of negotiation or whether a hearing took place, against the file itself. A summary that is wrong about a pricing driver will mislead you.

Ask the same questions of every file so the summaries can be compared. How many documents were produced? How many rounds of comments? Did the other side instruct a lawyer? Was there a dispute? A consistent set of questions turns a pile of files into data.

Define the scope in plain words

A fixed fee is only as good as the description of what it buys. Write the scope as a list of things the client will receive and a list of things they will not.

  • The documents you will draft or review, and how many rounds of comments are included.
  • The meetings or calls included, and their expected length.
  • Who will do the work and at what level of seniority.
  • What is excluded, such as disputes arising after completion, work for third parties or filings in other countries.
  • What counts as a change in scope, and who decides.
What the client receives
  • The documents drafted or reviewed, and rounds of comments.
  • The meetings or calls included.
  • Who will do the work and at what seniority.
What is excluded
  • Disputes arising after completion.
  • Work for third parties.
  • Filings in other countries.
What a fixed-fee scope should list

Exclusions: the part that protects the firm

Most overruns come from events the fee did not contemplate: a counterparty who negotiates extensively, a client who changes instructions, a document set that is bigger than expected, a deadline brought forward. Name these as exclusions or triggers. Say what happens when one occurs, such as a separate agreed fee or a return to hourly rates.

Be reasonable. Exclusions that swallow the fee make it meaningless, and clients notice.

Test the wording with a colleague who was not involved. If they read the scope and exclusions and cannot say whether a given request would be covered, the wording needs to be clearer. The place to find a disagreement is a conversation before the work, not an invoice after it.

Send the scope to the client in a short document, not buried in terms and conditions. Ask them to confirm that it matches what they expect. A client who has read and agreed the scope is far less likely to dispute the fee later.

Build in a review point

For work that runs over weeks or months, set a point at which both sides check the scope. It might be after the first draft or when the other side responds. If the work is on track, nothing changes. If it has drifted, you have a natural moment to discuss it before the fee is under strain.

A review point also protects the relationship, because the client hears about the change early and from you.

Write the review point into the engagement letter, with the question to be asked: is the work still what we agreed? That makes it a normal event rather than an awkward renegotiation.

Check the numbers after the matter closes

Keep recording time on fixed-fee work. When a matter closes, compare recorded time with the fee and note why they differ. After ten or twenty matters, you will see whether the fee is right, whether the exclusions are working and where a tool is saving real effort.

Do not lower the fee just because drafting is quicker unless the data supports it. Equally, do not keep it high if matters consistently come in well under. Clients can compare offers.

Share what you learn across the firm. A partner who prices one type of matter well should show the others how, including the spreadsheet or the note that records the reasoning.

  1. 1Record time throughout the matter
  2. 2Compare recorded time with the fee
  3. 3Note why they differ
  4. 4Judge the fee and exclusions after ten or twenty matters
  5. 5Price the next matter from the data
  6. Then back to step 1.
Learning from each closed fixed-fee matter

What AI cannot tell you

A tool cannot tell you what the market will pay, how risky a particular client is, or how much you value the relationship. It cannot tell you whether the other side will be difficult. Those are matters of commercial judgment and local knowledge.

Check the guidance from your regulator or bar on fee agreements and on what you must tell the client about costs. Put the fee and its scope in writing before work begins.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Fixed-fee legal pricing with AI-assisted scoping