ChamberOne

Recovering unrecorded time: how AI time capture works and its limits

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Ask any finance manager where a firm loses money without noticing and the answer is often the same: time that was worked and never recorded. A phone call after lunch, a document reviewed on a train, an hour of research that slipped between two meetings. Tools that suggest time entries from calendars, email and documents promise to catch some of it. They can help. They can also produce entries that are wrong, and an invoice is a statement to a client. This article looks at how they work and where they stop.

Key points

  • Most unrecorded time is lost to memory and delay, so daily recording matters more than any tool.
  • Suggestion tools match activity to matters and propose entries, but the matching is a guess.
  • Expect wrong matters, wrong durations and missing work with no digital trace.
  • The fee earner must confirm each entry. A suggestion is a prompt, not a record.
  • Explain to staff what data is read, and do not turn the tool into surveillance.

Why time goes unrecorded

Most missing time is not dishonesty. It is the cost of remembering. Fee earners are interrupted all day and record time later from memory, and memory is selective. Short tasks are forgotten first, and short tasks add up.

The longer the gap between the work and the record, the more is lost. A timesheet filled in on Friday for the whole week will be both shorter and less accurate than one filled in daily.

Suppose a three-partner firm asks its fee earners to estimate how much time they think they lose in a week. Most name a modest figure. When the firm compares calendars with timesheets for one month, the gaps are larger than anyone guessed, concentrated in short calls and emails. That comparison, not a new tool, is the first useful step.

How suggestion tools work, in general

Tools of this kind look at traces of activity and propose entries. Sources may include calendar appointments, sent and received email, documents opened or edited and calls logged. The tool matches an activity to a matter, estimates duration, and drafts a description. The fee earner then accepts, edits or rejects each one.

The quality depends on how good the matching is. A meeting titled with a client's name is easy. An email thread about three matters is not.

Where suggestions help

  • Reminding you of short tasks you would otherwise forget, such as a quick call or a brief email.
  • Filling gaps in a day with a prompt, so you can see where the hours went.
  • Drafting descriptions you can edit rather than write from nothing.
  • Reducing the time spent on the timesheet itself.
  • Making end-of-month catch-up less painful.

Where they go wrong

A suggestion is a guess about what you did. Expect errors of these kinds.

  • Wrong matter. An email that mentions two clients may be attributed to the wrong one.
  • Wrong duration. Time an email was open is not the time spent thinking about it.
  • Activity that is not work on a matter, such as reading a document for another purpose.
  • Missing work: thinking, travel, conversations in the corridor and anything that leaves no digital trace.
  • Descriptions that sound plausible but do not say what you did.
Where suggestions help
  • Reminding you of short tasks.
  • Filling gaps in a day with a prompt.
  • Drafting descriptions you can edit.
  • Reducing time spent on the timesheet.
Where they go wrong
  • Wrong matter.
  • Wrong duration.
  • Activity that is not work on a matter.
  • Missing work that leaves no digital trace.
  • Plausible but vague descriptions.
Where time suggestions help and where they go wrong

The fee earner confirms every entry

Time entries end up on invoices, and an invoice is a statement to a client. The person who did the work is the only one who knows what they did and how long it took. A suggestion should be treated as a prompt, never as a record, and nothing should be billed because a tool proposed it.

Check the guidance from your regulator or bar on charging for time and on the accuracy of bills. Where entries are accepted in bulk without reading, the firm risks overcharging, and that is a matter for professional conduct as well as for customer relations.

Privacy and staff trust

Tools that read email and calendars raise legitimate questions among staff. What exactly is being looked at? Who can see it? Is it used for anything other than suggesting time? Answer these openly before introducing a tool.

Check where the data is processed and what is kept, and whether the tool is reading content or only metadata such as subject lines and times. Staff are more likely to use a tool they understand and trust.

Offer an opt-out for a defined set of things, such as personal appointments and matters under a confidentiality wall. A tool that reads everything with no way to exclude anything will meet resistance, and rightly.

Be careful about using suggestion data to monitor people. If staff suspect that the tool is a surveillance system, they will stop using it, or use it defensively.

A sensible way to introduce it

Try it with a small group first. Before starting, measure how much time they record per day. After a month, compare. Ask them how many suggestions were right, how many needed editing and how many were wrong. The honest answers tell you whether the tool is a net saving.

Pair the tool with a habit. A five-minute review at the end of each day, with suggestions on screen, usually beats a long session at the end of the month. Keep a plain, non-technical timer or note-taking method for the work that leaves no trace.

For the work that leaves no digital trace, make recording as light as possible. A single line in a notes app, made straight after a conversation, takes ten seconds and is more accurate than any reconstruction.

  1. 1Review suggestions on screen at the end of the day
  2. 2Confirm, edit or reject each one
  3. 3Add untraced work with a one-line note
  4. 4Submit the day's entries
  5. 5Repeat tomorrow
  6. Then back to step 1.
A daily time-suggestion routine

What recovered time does and does not mean

Recovered time is only valuable if it is billable and billed. On fixed-fee matters it will not change an invoice, but it will improve your data about what the work costs, which helps you price the next one. On hourly matters, remember that clients may query bills. Accurate, well-described entries are the best answer.

Finance managers should also watch for the opposite problem: time that is recorded but should not be billed, such as time spent learning a tool or correcting its output. Decide the firm's position on that in advance and apply it consistently.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Recovering unrecorded time with AI time capture | ChamberOne