ChamberOne

Charging clients for AI-assisted work: what is fair

By the ChamberOne team 4 minute read

A task that took three hours last year takes one hour with a good tool. What should the client pay? The question divides firms. Some say the client should share the benefit. Others say the firm invested in the tool and the lawyer's judgement is what is being bought. Neither answer is complete without the facts: how the firm charges, what the client agreed, and what the regulator expects. This article does not tell you what the rules require. It sets out the questions a partner or ethics officer should settle, and the principles that tend to survive scrutiny.

Key points

  • The answer depends on the fee model, so check your regulator's guidance on reasonable fees.
  • Bill time actually spent by people, including time spent checking AI output.
  • Do not pass on tool costs the client has not been told about, and show any that you do as a separate line.
  • Be open in the engagement letter, and expect clients to ask for fixed fees on repeatable work.

Start with how you charge

The answer depends on the fee model. Under hourly billing, the client pays for time spent, so the honest course is to bill the time actually taken, however short. Under a fixed fee, the price is agreed for the outcome, and the time taken matters less to the client, though the price should have been set fairly. Under a value-based or success arrangement, the question is mostly about what was agreed.

Check the guidance from your regulator or bar on charging and on what counts as a reasonable fee. It differs between jurisdictions, and nothing here replaces it.

Billing time honestly

Time records should reflect the time a person spent, including time spent writing instructions to a tool, reading and checking its output. They should not be inflated to the time the task 'would have taken' without the tool. A bill that charges for work a machine did, as though a person did it, invites a dispute and may raise professional conduct questions.

Equally, do not hide the checking. Review time is real work and a proper part of the bill. A client is paying for a lawyer's judgement over the output, and that takes time.

Passing on tool costs

Firms spend money on software, and AI tools often add subscription or usage costs. Can they be charged to clients? Some firms treat them as overhead, like the cost of a document management system. Others consider charging direct costs of a particular matter, such as an unusually large document review that used metered processing.

Whatever the firm decides, do not add a charge the client has not been told about. If you intend to pass on a cost, say so in the engagement letter, state how it is calculated, and show it as a separate line. Check whether your regulator has views on charging for overhead and technology.

Being open in the engagement letter

  • State the basis of your charges: hourly rates, fixed fee or another model.
  • Say whether any technology costs will be passed on and how they will be shown.
  • Say that time billed reflects time actually spent by people.
  • Explain that the firm may use AI-based tools and that lawyers review output.
  • Invite questions about fees and tools, and say whom to ask.

Who benefits from efficiency?

Clients increasingly expect that quicker work will cost less, and some will ask for fixed fees or caps on routine tasks for that reason. Firms can respond in different ways: offer fixed prices for repeatable work, charge hourly and let the lower hours show, or reinvest the time in more careful review.

There is no universal answer, but there is a bad one: to bill as before and say nothing, hoping nobody notices. Clients talk to each other, and their advisers know what tools exist. A firm that is open about how technology affects its prices is likely to keep the relationship.

Fixed fees and the risk shift

Fixed fees put the efficiency risk on the firm. If a tool makes the work quicker than expected, the firm benefits. If it produces errors that need rework, the firm bears the cost. That makes careful scoping and quality control important. Before offering fixed prices, measure how long the task takes with the tool, including checking, on a number of past matters.

Be careful not to cut corners on review to protect the margin. A lawyer must still review the work, and the fee should allow for it.

Hourly billing
  • The client pays for time actually spent
  • Bill the time taken, however short
  • Time includes instructing the tool and checking its output
Fixed fee
  • The price is agreed for the outcome
  • The efficiency risk sits with the firm
  • Rework from errors is the firm's cost
  • The fee should allow for lawyer review
Hourly billing and fixed fees

A short scenario

Suppose a small firm bills a client hourly for a contract review. The associate uses a tool for a first pass and spends ninety minutes in total, including checking. The firm bills ninety minutes. The client asks how the review was done. The partner explains that a tool helped with the first read, and that the associate checked every flagged clause against the contract. The narrative shows the work. The client is satisfied, and next time asks for a fixed price for the same kind of review. The firm now has real figures from which to offer one.

Disbursements and third-party tools

Some tools are bought for one client, such as a document review platform with per-document charges, or a translation service. These resemble other disbursements: a real cost, incurred for the matter, at a price the firm can show. Treat them the way your firm treats other third-party costs, with the client's agreement and a copy of the invoice if asked.

Do not add a mark-up unless your regulator's guidance and your agreement allow it. A mark-up on a technology cost is a common source of complaints, and a clear policy avoids them.

Do
  • Bill the time a person actually spent
  • Show passed-on costs as a separate line
  • Say in the engagement letter if costs will be passed on
Don't
  • Inflate time to what the task would have taken
  • Add a charge the client has not been told about
  • Add a mark-up unless your regulator and agreement allow it
Charging for AI-assisted work

Questions for an ethics officer to settle

Does our time recording policy say that time must reflect actual effort? Do we have a rule on charging for software? Does the engagement letter mention technology? Does the billing partner review narratives for accuracy? Do we know what our regulator says about fees, and has someone checked it recently? Writing the answers down turns an uncomfortable debate into a policy.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next