ChamberOne

Estimating matter profitability before you accept it

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

Most firms know which clients they like, and few know which matters make money. A conveyance that looked straightforward ran for three months. A fixed-fee will turned into a family quarrel. Nobody added it up, and the next one was quoted at the same price. Estimating profitability before taking on a matter does not need sophisticated software. It needs records of what the last twenty similar matters actually took.

Key points

  • Estimate profitability at intake, when you can still change the price, the scope or the decision.
  • Use past matters of the same type, and look at the range, not just the average.
  • Include write-off and payment risk, not only hours.
  • Use a one-page worksheet and record the decision to accept, change terms or decline.
  • Compare actual results with the estimate after each matter to improve the next one.

Why estimate before, not after

Looking at profit once a matter is closed is useful for learning, but too late for the decision. The moment of influence is at intake, when you can still set the price, define the scope, ask for a deposit or decline. A short estimate at that stage turns a hope into a number you can discuss with a client or a partner.

It also improves the conversation about price. A partner who can say 'matters like this have typically taken between this and that many hours' is more convincing than one who gives a figure and hopes.

Build the evidence from past matters

Start with the matter types you handle most often, and gather data from the last year or two. For each closed matter, you want a few simple facts.

  • The matter type and any feature that made it harder, such as a contested issue or multiple parties.
  • Hours recorded, by grade of fee earner.
  • What was billed, what was collected and what was written off.
  • How long it took from opening to closing.
  • Any disbursements that you carried and any that you recovered.

Turn the evidence into an estimate

For each matter type, look at the range, not just the average. If a will usually takes five to eight hours but sometimes thirty, the spread tells you about risk. Note what pushed the long ones out: a difficult family, a missing document, a late change of instructions. Those become questions to ask at intake.

Then work out margin. Multiply the hours by the cost of the people who did the work, include a fair share of overheads, and compare with what was collected. The figure will not be precise, but it will show whether a type of work pays for itself. A matter type that regularly loses money at the standard fee is telling you something.

Estimate write-off risk

Hours are only part of the picture. Money that is billed but not collected is a cost too. Look at which types of matter and which kinds of client have a history of late payment, disputed bills or write-offs. Fee arrangements matter here. Work billed in stages with money on account carries less risk than work billed at the end.

At intake, ask what you know about the client's ability and willingness to pay, whether payment is likely to depend on a result, and whether the fee will come from a third party. These are commercial judgements, and the evidence from past matters helps you make them with your eyes open.

A simple intake worksheet

Put the estimate on a single page, completed by the partner and the person responsible for finances. A short worksheet is likely to be used. A long one will not.

  1. 1

    Matter type and the nearest comparable past matters.

  2. 2

    Estimated hours by grade, with a low and high figure.

  3. 3

    Estimated disbursements and who pays them.

  4. 4

    Proposed fee arrangement and the fee in each scenario.

  5. 5

    Main risks to scope and to payment, and how each will be handled.

  6. 6

    Expected margin at the low, middle and high estimate.

  7. 7

    Decision: accept, accept on changed terms, or decline, with the reason.

Declining work knowingly

Sometimes the numbers say a matter will not pay. You may accept it anyway, for good reasons: a long-standing client, a matter that builds expertise, or work that the firm values for its own sake. The point is that the decision is conscious, recorded and limited, not an accident.

When you decline, do so courteously and, where appropriate, suggest another route, such as a different firm or a different scope. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar on declining instructions and on referring clients, since rules differ. A clear and kind refusal protects the relationship better than an unprofitable engagement carried out resentfully.

Where AI can help, and where it cannot

AI tools can help with the arithmetic and the sorting: grouping past matters by type from free-text descriptions, spotting patterns in the time records, or summarising the notes on what made a matter harder than expected. They are poor at telling you what a new matter will cost, because that depends on the facts, the client and the other side, and on a record that is only as good as the data entered.

Treat any figures a tool produces as a lead to check. Look at the underlying matters yourself, and ask whether the sample is large enough and similar enough to mean anything. If time recording is patchy, fix that first. No analysis is better than the records behind it.

AI can help with
  • Grouping past matters by type from free-text descriptions
  • Spotting patterns in time records
  • Summarising notes on what made a matter harder
AI is poor at
  • Telling you what a new matter will cost
  • Allowing for the facts, client and other side
  • Making up for patchy records
AI and matter profitability

A hypothetical example

Suppose a four-partner firm looks at forty closed residential leasehold matters. Most took a modest number of hours and collected in full. A handful ran long because the other side was slow to answer and the client kept changing instructions. When the partners look at what the long ones had in common, they find three warning signs at intake: a client with no clear decision-maker, a missing title document and a deadline set by someone else. They add three questions to the intake form and a clause in the engagement letter about what happens if instructions change.

Review after the matter

Close the loop. When a matter finishes, compare the actual figures with the estimate and note the reasons for any difference. After a few months, you will see where your estimates are consistently too optimistic and can adjust. Over a year, the intake worksheet becomes the firm's most reliable picture of its own business.

  1. 1Estimate hours and margin at intake
  2. 2Do the work and record time
  3. 3Compare actual figures with the estimate
  4. 4Note the reasons for any difference
  5. 5Adjust the next estimate
  6. Then back to step 1.
Learning from each matter's estimate

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Estimating matter profitability before you accept it