ChamberOne

Write-offs and realisation rate: what your numbers are telling you

By the ChamberOne team 5 minute read

A fee earner records a hundred hours on a matter. The invoice goes out for ninety. The client pays eighty-five after a query. Somewhere between recording and collecting, value disappeared. Realisation is the name for what is left, and write-offs are the name for what went. Understanding both helps a firm decide whether the problem is pricing, process or people, and AI-assisted work is making the question harder to answer.

Key points

  • Say which realisation you mean: billing, collection or overall.
  • Find where write-offs happen in the journey, and record reasons for each.
  • AI-assisted work can reduce recorded time; decide how review time is handled.
  • Use the figures to start conversations, not to penalise honest recording.

Realisation, defined carefully

Realisation compares what you recorded with what you got. There are at least three versions, and firms often mix them up. Billing realisation compares the value billed with the value of time recorded. Collection realisation compares cash collected with the value billed. Overall realisation compares cash collected with the value of time recorded.

State which one you mean every time. A firm that bills nearly everything but collects slowly has a different problem from a firm that writes down heavily before invoicing.

Where value leaks

Think of the journey as a pipe with holes at known places.

  • Before billing: time written off by the fee earner or partner because the work was inefficient, a training exercise or beyond the estimate.
  • At invoice review: reductions made by the partner to keep the bill reasonable or match a client's expectation.
  • After invoicing: discounts negotiated after a client query, or credit notes.
  • After a dispute: bills challenged or assessed, and reduced.
  • Never collected: bad debt, where the client does not pay and the firm stops chasing.

Reading the pattern

Look at where the write-offs occur, not just how large they are. If most reductions happen at partner review, the signal is about expectations: fee earners record time that partners do not think is chargeable, or estimates were too low. If reductions happen after the bill is sent, the client did not understand what they were paying for, and the engagement letter or communication may be at fault.

Group write-offs by practice area, client type, fee arrangement and fee earner, and look for concentration. A single client or a single matter type can account for most of the leakage. Reasons matter too. Require a short reason code on every write-off, and review the codes quarterly.

Common causes and what to do about them

  • Under-scoped fixed fees. The price was set without looking at history. Review fixed fees against actual time, and price using your own data.
  • Late billing. The longer time sits unbilled, the harder it is to justify. Set a rule on billing frequency and monitor WIP.
  • Poorly described time entries. Vague narratives invite challenge. Encourage specific entries.
  • Unclear engagement terms. Set expectations on scope and costs in writing at the start.
  • Trainee and learning time. Decide in advance how it is treated and do not leave it to be written off at the end.

Every one of these is a conversation as much as a process. Realisation figures are best used to start the conversation.

How AI-assisted work changes the pattern

If AI shortens a task that used to take hours, the recorded time falls. Under hourly billing, so does the fee. That can lower revenue per matter while quality is unchanged or better. Under fixed fees, the saving stays with the firm. Neither effect shows up clearly in realisation unless you look for it.

Another effect is more subtle. Review time on AI output may be recorded or not. Some firms write it off as an overhead, which depresses realisation; others bill it. Decide your policy and apply it consistently, or comparisons across fee earners become meaningless.

Clients may also push back on charges for work they believe a machine did. Be ready to explain that the fee reflects the lawyer's judgement and responsibility. Check the guidance from your regulator or bar on how fees should be explained and what clients must be told about the use of technology.

Under hourly billing
  • Recorded time falls, and so does the fee
  • Revenue per matter can drop while quality is unchanged or better
Under fixed fees
  • The saving stays with the firm
  • Neither effect shows clearly in realisation unless you look for it
How faster work shows up in the numbers

Setting up reporting

  1. 1

    Choose one definition of realisation for the partner report and write it down.

  2. 2

    Record write-offs as separate transactions with a reason code and the name of who approved them.

  3. 3

    Report realisation by practice area, fee arrangement and client group monthly.

  4. 4

    Compare hourly and fixed-fee matters separately.

  5. 5

    Flag matters where recorded time exceeds the budget before they are billed, so the conversation happens early.

  6. 6

    Review the reason codes every quarter and change a process where a pattern appears.

A note of caution

Chasing a high realisation figure for its own sake can backfire. Pressure to avoid write-offs may lead fee earners to under-record time, hiding inefficiency and distorting the data you rely on. Some write-offs are the right decision: the firm made a mistake, or the client relationship matters more.

Use realisation to understand, not to punish. The aim is a firm that prices fairly, records honestly and gets paid for work that clients value.

Do
  • Use it to understand where value leaks
  • Price fairly and record time honestly
  • Accept that some write-offs are the right decision
Don't
  • Chase a high figure for its own sake
  • Use it to punish fee earners
  • Pressure people into under-recording time
Using realisation sensibly

A hypothetical example

Suppose a small firm has hourly and fixed-fee matters in the same practice area. Overall realisation looks acceptable, but when the firm splits it, the hourly matters collect almost everything they bill, while the fixed-fee matters lose a large share of recorded time between recording and invoice. Nobody chose that outcome; it came from fixed fees set a few years ago and never revisited.

The partners do not blame the fee earners. They look at the closed fixed-fee files, find the phases that regularly overran, reprice the product and add a scope clause to the engagement letter. A year later the split looks different. The lesson is that the aggregate figure hid a problem that only the breakdown could show.

Questions to ask at the partners' meeting

Which matters had the largest write-offs this quarter, and what reason code was recorded? Were any of them predictable at the start? Which clients are consistently reduced, and is that deliberate? Who approved the biggest reductions, and did they discuss them with the fee earner? Has the budget for any current matter already been exceeded?

These questions are short, but they require data that a firm with no reason codes cannot answer. Setting up the coding is dull work that pays for itself the first time a pattern emerges.

This article is general information about the law, legal practice and technology, current when it was published. It is not legal advice. Laws and guidance change: check the sources linked above and take advice on your own circumstances from a lawyer qualified where you are.

Read next

Write-offs and realisation rate explained for law firms